I have a question for our moderator, Borski. Elon is the owner of Tesla and direct competitor of Lucid. In his role as an advisor to the president with apparently a strong influence on government decisions that can favor Tesla over Lucid and other EV makers, would a discussion on this subject be disallowed?
Good question. I don’t know. To be honest, the hard and fast “no politics” rule had to change somewhat, because EVs, as you mention, are unfortunately now political in nature. But only in the media and public discourse; there isn’t anything *actually* inherently political about them.
Look, this isn’t actually that complicated: we just want civility. We want people to be able to say what they want to say, but maintain an open forum for discussion, and not start throwing insults or ad hominem or offensive language around.
Trans rights, or the department of education, to use two random examples, has absolutely nothing to do with anything here. Discussing them, no matter how I or anyone else feel about it, is best left for other places. Same goes for dozens of other topics.
Elon and Tesla are an interesting one, along with oil / our new “energy emergency” or whatever we’re calling it, because they… *are* quite related, despite being inherently political now.
So my answer, I guess, really remains the same: if people can have a reasoned and decent discussion, without resorting to name-calling, being offensive just to be offensive, or talking past each other… great.
That isn’t how political discussions here tend to go down. I *love* discussing politics. It’s actually one of my favorite things to do (really). That and philosophy. Two of my most common topics with friends.
But this isn’t a board of just my friends, and I understand that discussing politics successfully means starting from a place of *respect*, as politics is inherently a somewhat intimate topic. It often involves topics that can easily become emotionally charged, by definition.
I’m not a king. I don’t even own this board. That’s
@Joe.
We just want it to be a place that remains fun, useful, respectful, entertaining, and positive. If people keep discussions calm and as described above, you won’t find us deleting anything.
But if people give us a reason to delete posts, we will; this board doesn’t exist to serve politics, or to please any one individual who wants to discuss politics here.
Have respectful discussions, and everything will be hunky-dory. Otherwise, there’s X. Have at it.
(But yes, off-topic exists for this reason now, with the caveat that it gets less traffic)