You need LIDAR

Status
Not open for further replies.
The guy you're telling is providing false information actually works at Google so he probably knows more than any of us how things work over there. Tell me, do you work at Google or Tesla or just read X, Reddit, Forums and the internet and think you know everything or whatever AI client you're getting your "facts" from?

Working at google has nothing to do with waymo. tesla literally employs 1000s of people who directly work on FSD who have no idea how it works.

The guy who is responding is repeating waymo's marketing information. Marketing information has nothing to do with what the car really does

Everyone markets their system as better than it really is. For example, waymo says they can drive without HD maps and camera only, but they do not have a safety level for unsupervised. There is a wide range of performance between unsupervised and no driving ability.

in the case of waymo hitting a telephone pole, they publicly responded and said that pole was assigned a low damage score in the map. When they sent a backup waymo to pick up the riders, they had to emergency stop the waymo to prevent it from hitting the same telephone pole


1794858195121.webp
 
Last edited:
Like I said, You need LIDAR!!! Or you can be killed using FSD. Your choice.

Don’t believe everything that comes out of a lying billionaire’s mouth.

If you read that accident report, it has nothing to do with lidar. It has to do with the car leaving the road, which FSD doesn't do.

If you read the accident report, the car was going 73mph. Sounds like autopilot where someone possibly set the speed to 73mph or somebody stepped on the accelerator pedal. That particular road, it is impossible to make FSD go that fast. The speed limit is 45mph, so even in mad max, you can't get above 55mph on a road with that many lights and stop signs.

The problem with NHTSA reports is they require an accident reported within 30s of adas engagement. That's too long of a window. You can easily disengage a system, crash it yourself and then be required to report it. 5 seconds is long enough that it is impossible to predict an accident and prevent automakers from shuting off the systems.
 
Last edited:
If you read that accident report, it has nothing to do with lidar. It has to do with the car leaving the road, which FSD doesn't do.

If you read the accident report, the car was going 73mph. Sounds like autopilot where someone possibly set the speed to 73mph or somebody stepped on the accelerator pedal. That particular road, it is impossible to make FSD go that fast. The speed limit is 45mph, so even in mad max, you can't get above 55mph on a road with that many lights and stop signs.

The problem with NHTSA reports is they require an accident reported within 30s of adas engagement. That's too long of a window. You can easily disengage a system, crash it yourself and then be required to report it. 5 seconds is long enough that it is impossible to predict an accident and prevent automakers from shuting off the systems.
Paste the accident report that you're telling people to read in its entirety like you "apparently" did. I bet you can't because CHP hasn't released it and Tesla redacted the NHTSA narrative.

This just proves you’re spamming threads with regurgitated LLM talking points without actually understanding what you're talking about!.
 
I'm not seeing the comment you're replied to, since I've made use of the ignore button. But I'll note that Musk has well documented instances of lying in response to press reports he didn't like. The one that immediately comes to mind is when Reuters reported that Tesla had canceled their low cost "Model 2" vehicle program, and Musk denied it. Within a few months it became clear that the Reuters report was correct. I wouldn't go so far as saying that everything Musk/Tesla says is false, but they also don't deserve a presumption of honesty at this point.
Yes, Musk lies….its quite obvious to everyone except the Tesla fanboys and fangirls
 
If you read that accident report, it has nothing to do with lidar. It has to do with the car leaving the road, which FSD doesn't do.

If you read the accident report, the car was going 73mph. Sounds like autopilot where someone possibly set the speed to 73mph or somebody stepped on the accelerator pedal. That particular road, it is impossible to make FSD go that fast. The speed limit is 45mph, so even in mad max, you can't get above 55mph on a road with that many lights and stop signs.

The problem with NHTSA reports is they require an accident reported within 30s of adas engagement. That's too long of a window. You can easily disengage a system, crash it yourself and then be required to report it. 5 seconds is long enough that it is impossible to predict an accident and prevent automakers from shuting off the systems.

So, Tesla FSD learns from humans, will NEVER be better than humans.

Time to get off your ketamine! Wakey wakey…….
 
Working at google has nothing to do with waymo. tesla literally employs 1000s of people who directly work on FSD who have no idea how it works.

The guy who is responding is repeating waymo's marketing information. Marketing information has nothing to do with what the car really does

Everyone markets their system as better than it really is. For example, waymo says they can drive without HD maps and camera only, but they do not have a safety level for unsupervised. There is a wide range of performance between unsupervised and no driving ability.

in the case of waymo hitting a telephone pole, they publicly responded and said that pole was assigned a low damage score in the map. When they sent a backup waymo to pick up the riders, they had to emergency stop the waymo to prevent it from hitting the same telephone pole


View attachment 42425
Yeah, Waymo recalls for safety, while Tesla continues to push out its vehicles with FSD even after blatant crashes…..dude, Musk doesn’t care if you live or die…..you don’t get that yet?

Mobada- A commoner going all out to protect a trillionaire who treats him like a test mule whose life is expendable in his quest to set up a colony on Mars…..hahahaha…..
 
Yeah, Waymo recalls for safety, while Tesla continues to push out its vehicles with FSD even after blatant crashes…..dude, Musk doesn’t care if you live or die…..you don’t get that yet?

Mobada- A commoner going all out to protect a trillionaire who treats him like a test mule whose life is expendable in his quest to set up a colony on Mars…..hahahaha…..
Or it's called not being ignorant about what others have? It's fine to have an option but you should at least try and do better research about the products others have.

just look at the NHTSA reports of ADS crashes in texas. Currently tesla is BEATING waymo in crash rate at speeds above 5mph. Clearly it's good accident avoidance, fast reaction that avoids these, not lidar.

Soon enough (I think tomorrow) NHTSA crash reports will contain mileage, and we will have apples to apples comparison, but at tesla's current growth rate they are already beating waymo in texas. They have about 150 cybercabs in dallas which will be registered in the next few days
 
Paste the accident report that you're telling people to read in its entirety like you "apparently" did. I bet you can't because CHP hasn't released it and Tesla redacted the NHTSA narrative.

This just proves you’re spamming threads with regurgitated LLM talking points without actually understanding what you're talking about!.
I appreciate that you're trying to get them to think critically of the information but I think they're too far gone for any of us to help. At this rate you can save your sanity and your time by outright blocking them
 
Paste the accident report that you're telling people to read in its entirety like you "apparently" did. I bet you can't because CHP hasn't released it and Tesla redacted the NHTSA narrative.

This just proves you’re spamming threads with regurgitated LLM talking points without actually understanding what you're talking about!.
have you never looked at the NHTSA SGO reports? Tesla reports every detail and only redacts the narrative and the exact location the crash happened. You can see where the car was hit, precrash speed, travel direction, etc.

You don't need the narrative to assess what happened.

FSD is not like waymo where it accelerates very fast up to the speed limit. It accelerates slow and takes quite a while to reach the speed limit/above it. That means there is only so fast FSD can go and going 73mph on a road like that is not possible.

We have a road exactly like that in atlanta, and FSD won't even hit the speed limit (nor does a human) because the road is too curvy, too many stop signs/stop lights

When tesla was redacting the robotaxi reports it was still easy to see that they were mostly being hit from behind while the tesla is at 0mph. That's called being not at fault
 
Working at google has nothing to do with waymo. tesla literally employs 1000s of people who directly work on FSD who have no idea how it works.

The guy who is responding is repeating waymo's marketing information. Marketing information has nothing to do with what the car really does

Everyone markets their system as better than it really is. For example, waymo says they can drive without HD maps and camera only, but they do not have a safety level for unsupervised. There is a wide range of performance between unsupervised and no driving ability.

in the case of waymo hitting a telephone pole, they publicly responded and said that pole was assigned a low damage score in the map. When they sent a backup waymo to pick up the riders, they had to emergency stop the waymo to prevent it from hitting the same telephone pole


View attachment 42425
Waymo is an Alphabet bet. One of my closest friends runs engineering there.

But you do you, man. I’m sure you think you’re perfectly right, with nothing at all left to learn, and no curiosity about things you may not know.

That’s fine, I just could not have any less desire to engage as a result. Enjoy your soapbox, and I’ll let others ignore you at will.

Have a lovely week.
 
Waymo is an Alphabet bet. One of my closest friends runs engineering there.

But you do you, man.

As if that means anything? Tesla has 2000 people who work on data labeling across 5 offices, directly under Tesla AI. They have absolutely no idea how FSD works and they all work right here in the U.S.
 
have you never looked at the NHTSA SGO reports? Tesla reports every detail and only redacts the narrative and the exact location the crash happened. You can see where the car was hit, precrash speed, travel direction, etc.

You don't need the narrative to assess what happened.

FSD is not like waymo where it accelerates very fast up to the speed limit. It accelerates slow and takes quite a while to reach the speed limit/above it. That means there is only so fast FSD can go and going 73mph on a road like that is not possible.

We have a road exactly like that in atlanta, and FSD won't even hit the speed limit (nor does a human) because the road is too curvy, too many stop signs/stop lights

When tesla was redacting the robotaxi reports it was still easy to see that they were mostly being hit from behind while the tesla is at 0mph. That's called being not at fault
Thanks Claude
 
Thanks Claude
You don't need AI for this, nor do I use AI for this.

There was an accident a couple months ago where "FSD" drove into a house at 73mph. There was also an accident using "FSD" crashed at 89mph.

FSD won't drive a neighborhood street at 73mph (and autopilot won't work on a neighborhood street), and then FSD won't go faster than 85mph

In the first example the guy pressed the accelerator pedal at 100% and drove the car into the house on his own. But again it's reported because FSD is engaged within 30s of a crash like tesla is legally required to do. The other one is clearly also not FSD because you can't go 89mph
 
As if that means anything? Tesla has 2000 people who work on data labeling across 5 offices, directly under Tesla AI. They have absolutely no idea how FSD works and they all work right here in the U.S.
Cool.
 
You don't need AI for this, nor do I use AI for this.

There was an accident a couple months ago where "FSD" drove into a house at 73mph. There was also an accident using "FSD" crashed at 89mph.

FSD won't drive a neighborhood street at 73mph (and autopilot won't work on a neighborhood street), and then FSD won't go faster than 85mph

In the first example the guy pressed the accelerator pedal at 100% and drove the car into the house on his own. But again it's reported because FSD is engaged within 30s of a crash like tesla is legally required to do. The other one is clearly also not FSD because you can't go 89mph
Cool.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top