I point out issues like memory bandwidth with the nvidia thor and people gloss over it like it's not some real issue
Sure, memory bandwidthb is important, but it isn't the end-all be-all.
There are serious drawbacks to the way the Tesla system is designed, and in some ways they are brute forcing their way to the current level of FSD.
There are other architectural designs in Thor that allow it to (theoretically) make better use of the memory bandwidth, and do so at much lower power (and thus heat) levels than Tesla.
Nvidia has a LOT more experience designing and then wringing maximum performance out of compute/graphics chipsets and systems than Tesla. They haven't dominated both the gaming and workstation GPU market by being stupid.
Is it a guarantee that it will exceed or even meet the overall performance that Tesla has? No, of course not, it's a complicated, emerging technology and there's never a guarantee a particular new way of doing things will work out.
But you're insane to pretend they don't know what they're doing, and I wouldn't bet against Thor being a very successful platform.