This thread has been really useful to read through again, because I am in the same spot with my 21s as winter gets closer and the summer tires are getting to the point where I do not want to rely on them much longer. The 255 front and 275 rear Michelin setup sounds like the most sensible compromise so far, especially hearing that LucidDream has done over 6000 miles on them with no rub, that is a lot more reassuring than just guessing from the sizes on paper. I am still a bit nervous about the shop side of it though, after reading about Discount Tire only mounting them and not installing them because of the 98XL rating, I can see my local place doing exactly the same thing and then I would be stuck. The u-turn scrubbing Aka-none mentioned is the other thing that puts me off a little, I do a lot of tight turns getting in and out of my driveway and I do not want to be hearing that every day. I did think about just switching to 20s like sdh1123 mentioned, but selling the 21s and starting again feels like a lot of hassle and cost for what is basically a tire problem. For now I think I will price up the 255 and 275 Michelins and ask a couple of independent shops what they will actually fit, rather than assuming the big chains will say yes. If anyone has had them fitted recently in a colder area, I would be interested to hear how they have held up once the temperatures really drop.