I know everyone here are professional collision industry repair specialists and I'm not, but that picture shows superficial wound. Can you give more details of the incident? Looks like a parking lot 2mph "didn't see ya" sort of deal.
Was that policy written during the first year of ownership? ie, before any nominal depreciation took place?If you don’t have agreed upon value insurance coverage I believe that it’s the insurance company’s call on the total loss settlement..my totaled 2023 AGT settlement was for my total purchase price plus taxes of $142000. Check your policy endorsements..
Agreed value insurance is typically not impacted by depreciation. What you describe is more typical of stated amount insurance. Those policies do consider depreciation.Was that policy written during the first year of ownership? ie, before any nominal depreciation took place?
I ask because my Cincinnati policy’s agreed upon value was $84,900, effectively the purchase price of my 2025 AT this year….I switched to them when my prior annual coverage ran out, which was Oct 2025, 10 months after taking delivery, and so still not quite considered a year old by the depreciation outfits.
The renewal, taking effect in a few days, drops it to $55,000. That’s probably pretty close to a fair market value (or replacement cost) now for an almost 2 year-old AT, that’s reflecting 1yr of depreciation.
This is my first true luxury vehicle, so my first experience with agreed value insurance. Is what I’m seeing more or less the typical approach, with the value still dropping annually with depreciation, but at least anchoring in a figure at the beginning of the coverage year, rather than potentially getting much less back if the car was totaled near the end of the coverage year (ie using then-current replacement market value)?
(FWIW, I was unable to get a response from Pure; Safeco was significantly more expensive, so Cinci was my best enhanced coverage option….the much higher and longer lasting rental car coverage is also key, thanks to interminable body shop times)
Huh. Cincinnati definitely calls this “agreed value”…?Agreed value insurance is typically not impacted by depreciation. What you describe is more typical of stated amount insurance. Those policies do consider depreciation.
The key to an agreed value policy is agreement on the value. It should be mutual. It looks like Cincinnati is restating the value at renewal to the current actual cash value. If that’s acceptable to you that will become your new “agreed” value. What you are essentially getting is a guarantee that the payout will be no less than the current ACV if a total loss happens at any point during the year. Essentially negating up to 12 months of depreciation. You could arrive at a higher new agreed value if Cincinnati is willing to do so.Huh. Cincinnati definitely calls this “agreed value”…?
i believe the lucid leases include GAP coverage which would take care of the difference.i am going to write up my experience in a separate thread. But briefly, no surprise at OP statement. I have a 2022 Lucid AGT that has depreciated some 65%. Had a 15mph front end run in to old Toyota pickup. Damage didnt look that bad. Estimate from a fully certified lucid repair shop at 44,000! Insurance going to total. about equal parts and labor. Only 4 shops in NW US to repair. Between the plastic and sheet metal with no structural steel and the incredible labor rates of 185/hr, then the dramatic depreciation, these cars are not repairable. I will not be buying another Lucid. I did ask them for help and all they said was the shop is charging too much for labor.
Then I asked about leasing to the shop owner. They said even worse as if I was under a lease i would be responsible for the difference between insurance value and end of lease value. Going back to tried and true and repairable large car company vehicles.
It remains to be seen if they were successful, but the interview with Cory Steuben, formerly with Munro, suggested they had repairability as a significant goal (along with manufacturing cost reduction) in the design of the Cosmos. I'm cautiously hopeful that they will succeed with the Cosmos and then be able to take those concepts into any potential future redesigns/refreshes of the Air and Gravity, as well as Earth and other future models.That is good to know. These cars have stratospheric repair costs and same depreciation. A bad combination.
The conundrum Lucid and Lucid owners face is that Lucid has small market presence and their parts are scares and expensive. Aside from the cost of repairs, one has to wait a long time to get parts. On top of that you have this thing about the shop being a premier provider to the insurance company. The end result are long waits and expensive parts.In late October 2026, I bumped someone who cut in front of me suddenly in 2025 Lucid Air GT. It’s been at the only certified Lucid shop in the area and the estimate for seemingly minor damage to the front driver’s side bumper and turn signal is now an 25k! Because the certified Lucid shop is not a premier State Farm partner, I’m facing a bill of nearly $10k out of pocket.
Needless to say, I’m quite shocked. Especially after owning a 2015 Tesla Model S that experienced severe hail damage costing $31k to repair (everything single panel on the car plus glass roof and windshield shattered) by golf ball sized hail) but the Tesla certified shop was a State Farm premier partner so I only paid my deductible.
Escalate the issue within State Farm. You cannot be disadvantaged because State Farm’s premier partners are not certified to repair Lucid’s. And if you’re unsuccessful in escalating advise State Farm that you’ll be contacting the Colorado Department of Insurance and then do so.In late October 2026, I bumped someone who cut in front of me suddenly in 2025 Lucid Air GT. It’s been at the only certified Lucid shop in the area and the estimate for seemingly minor damage to the front driver’s side bumper and turn signal is now an 25k! Because the certified Lucid shop is not a premier State Farm partner, I’m facing a bill of nearly $10k out of pocket.
Needless to say, I’m quite shocked. Especially after owning a 2015 Tesla Model S that experienced severe hail damage costing $31k to repair (everything single panel on the car plus glass roof and windshield shattered) by golf ball sized hail) but the Tesla certified shop was a State Farm premier partner so I only paid my deductible.
Excellent advice. The only other solution I can suggest is switch to a better insurance company. My PURE insurance is more expensive, but they cover all costs related to repairs. And will not give you a hard time.Escalate the issue within State Farm. You cannot be disadvantaged because State Farm’s premier partners are not certified to repair Lucid’s. And if you’re unsuccessful in escalating advise State Farm that you’ll be contacting the Colorado Department of Insurance and then do so.
Went through a very similar situation with also minor damage and a $24k repair. The body shop warned me about the insurance risk. But at the end GEICO ended up paying the claim. The funny part is that GEICO's initial quote for the repair was $1,600 and they stated that I should procure the parts on eBay. The body shop told me they'd only put original parts btwIn late October 2026, I bumped someone who cut in front of me suddenly in 2025 Lucid Air GT. It’s been at the only certified Lucid shop in the area and the estimate for seemingly minor damage to the front driver’s side bumper and turn signal is now an 25k! Because the certified Lucid shop is not a premier State Farm partner, I’m facing a bill of nearly $10k out of pocket.
Needless to say, I’m quite shocked. Especially after owning a 2015 Tesla Model S that experienced severe hail damage costing $31k to repair (everything single panel on the car plus glass roof and windshield shattered) by golf ball sized hail) but the Tesla certified shop was a State Farm premier partner so I only paid my deductible.
Thank you for the suggestion but the Colorado DOI website even states the following:Escalate the issue within State Farm. You cannot be disadvantaged because State Farm’s premier partners are not certified to repair Lucid’s. And if you’re unsuccessful in escalating advise State Farm that you’ll be contacting the Colorado Department of Insurance and then do so.
You may have more leverage than what you think, or have been told, particularly given the limited repair options for Lucid vehicles.Thank you for the suggestion but the Colorado DOI website even states the following:
The company will pay reasonable market costs; however, they may not pay additional fees or excessive costs charged by the repair facility. See Section 10-4-120, C.R.S. Unreasonable costs, such as excessive storage fees or labor rates, etc. may not be paid in full.
This is exactly what the shop and State Farm told me, each blaming the other.
Given that my wife is an attorney, I’m familiar with contract laws but far from expert with it. My understanding is that the only real alternative is to file a legal challenge against State Farm which could drag on for years and could cost far more than 10k, and I still might not triumph.You may have more leverage than what you think, or have been told, particularly given the limited repair options for Lucid vehicles.
Without getting into the legal weeds, insurance contracts are considered “contracts of adhesion” meaning that you have no ability to negotiate them. The contract must meet the reasonable expectations of the insured. And it’s reasonable to expect that the policy will fully cover repairs even if options are limited. Put another way, you could select another more reasonably priced shop if the insurer can identify one. They cannot. And in those instances the contract language becomes entirely one sided and may be considered unconscionable under law.
Well, I guess I did get into the weeds.
This is why state’s regulate insurance companies through department’s of insurance. I make no assumptions on whether or not you’d be successful, but engaging the DOI costs nothing and could save you $10K. And your argument may be bolstered if State Farm acknowledges that there are no premier partners in the State of Colorado capable of repairing Lucid vehicles. You can’t enforce an obligation that an owner can’t reasonably comply with.Given that my wife is an attorney, I’m familiar with contract laws but far from expert with it. My understanding is that the only real alternative is to file a legal challenge against State Farm which could drag on for years and could cost far more than 10k, and I still might not triumph.
I will certainly attempt to escalate within State Farm and I’m certainly not opposed to becoming more forceful if necessary. But my experience with State Farm is not positive in this regard.
This is why state’s regulate insurance companies through department’s of insurance. I make no assumptions on whether or not you’d be successful, but engaging the DOI costs nothing and could save you $10K. And your argument may be bolstered if State Farm acknowledges that there are no premier partners in the State of Colorado capable of repairing Lucid vehicles. You can’t enforce an obligation that an owner can’t reasonably comply with.
Couple years back, a forum member, who's not a lawyer and neither is his wife, went thru a similar thing. He appealed with the Illinois Insurance commissioner's office and got the insurance to pay up.Given that my wife is an attorney, I’m familiar with contract laws but far from expert with it. My understanding is that the only real alternative is to file a legal challenge against State Farm which could drag on for years and could cost far more than 10k, and I still might not triumph.
I will certainly attempt to escalate within State Farm and I’m certainly not opposed to becoming more forceful if necessary. But my experience with State Farm is not positive in this regard.