Cosmos incoming ……

Agreed. If the Cosmos arrives in the US $5,000 to $10,000 above similarly equipped Model Y, then Cosmos will fail to be the high volume car Lucid needs it to be for survival. The Cosmos to succeed as the new option it needs to be priced on par with Model Y but be BETTER. That’s a tall order and it will never happen if they make Cosmos in Saudi Arabia in import them to the US with shipping and tariff charges.
People will send more for something better. And Cosmos will be better. Better looking, by far. Better driving. Better efficiency. Better cache.

It’s also going to be new and exciting. Which is the last thing anyone would say about a Model Y.

The only reason to go Y will be if you really buy into FSD (fair enough) or if you want the cheapest thing. Or if it’s a peer pressure thing and all your friends go Tesla, etc.

Tons of people looking for more fun to drive EVs. And very few delivering that.
 
But a $50k Cosmos is barebones, while that’s a reasonably well equipped Model Y. The average Cosmos is likely going to be close to $70k, given how many people go for the $100k+ Air and Gravity models.

But yes. It’s the higher end folks getting the nicer Y that Lucid needs to focus on.
Well I hope you're wrong. Because a $70K Cosmos would likely be the demise of the company. They simply don't have the balance sheet to support the sale of another low volume vehicle.
The argument that Cosmos is a better vehicle is the same rationale that hasn't resonated with either the Air or Gravity. The better vehicle will always be the one that sells and generates profits.
 
Well I hope you're wrong. Because a $70K Cosmos would likely be the demise of the company. They simply don't have the balance sheet to support the sale of another low volume vehicle.
The argument that Cosmos is a better vehicle is the same rationale that hasn't resonated with either the Air or Gravity. The better vehicle will always be the one that sells and generates profits.
Nobody said the Cosmos would start at 70k. But when people pick options, it will likely be above the base price (which will be around or under 50k).

So you’ll still be able to buy the base model for 50k or less.
 
Nobody said the Cosmos would start at 70k. But when people pick options, it will likely be above the base price (which will be around or under 50k).

So you’ll still be able to buy the base model for 50k or less.
If the average is closer to $50K vs. $70K the company will have a fighting chance. Because if the intent is to sell volume in the 10’s of thousands that’s where the market is at. They need volume (and profits) to offset the investments they’ve made in production capacity. Cosmos can’t be a niche offering if the company is going to survive.
 
But a $50k Cosmos is barebones, while that’s a reasonably well equipped Model Y. The average Cosmos is likely going to be close to $70k, given how many people go for the $100k+ Air and Gravity models.

But yes. It’s the higher end folks getting the nicer Y that Lucid needs to focus on.
$70k would put it $10k above the Performance R2... a tough sell
 
Aiming for Cosmos as my first Lucid. Don't need it loaded. 50-60k would be my sweet spot.

Sure there's similar prices Volvos, Beemers, etc but are you going to buy the trim you want from the dealer for the price you expect? Lucid can do well in this segment of the market like the MY does.
 
The Saudi's are not just committed to building Cosmos but buying it as well. The same can't be said for the Europe or the US.

Per the 10-K:
Pursuant to the terms of the EV Purchase Agreement, the Government of Saudi Arabia and its entities and corporate subsidiaries and other beneficiaries (collectively, the“Purchaser”) may purchase up to 100,000 vehicles, with a minimum purchase quantity of 50,000 vehicles and an option to purchase up to an additional 50,000 vehicles during a ten-year period.

Obviously the US market is important, but the KSA has a lot more skin in the game. The decision to build Cosmos in the KSA is intertwined with the government's purchase agreement.

50k minimum over 10 years is essentially meaningless. That commitment won't help Lucid survive if Cosmos is not successful.

If Cosmos doesn't sell close to 50k in its first year of production alone then Lucid probably won't survive.
 
70k means you're competing with iX3, glc, and EX60 on pricing.

Cosmos might be better than all of them but it probably won't be so much better that people cautious about buying from a new company will be convinced. All 3 of those EVs are good enough in pretty much every way. And once again, Cosmos is supposed to be the iX4/GLC coupe competitor meaning some buyers might not even consider it at all. The Earth should have been released first.

They need to be targeting R2 pricing with 60k being the high end, excluding a sapphire trim later on.
 
50k minimum over 10 years is essentially meaningless. That commitment won't help Lucid survive if Cosmos is not successful.

If Cosmos doesn't sell close to 50k in its first year of production alone then Lucid probably won't survive.
Sad, but true!
 
I'm honestly not worried about how the car looks, drives, packaging, efficiency, etc. Everything they've relayed so far suggests it will be class leading in those respects. Also, BMW and Mercedes have set the bar quite high for luxury car pricing in this segment. I'd be surprised if Cosmos matches or exceeds that pricing.

I'm more worried about overall execution: production ramp, software, fit and finish, service network, etc. Flopping on those will be what shuts Lucid down, not being incrementally more expensive than Tesla.
 
The better vehicle will always be the one that sells and generates profits.
I'd call that the more successful vehicle, not the better vehicle. I think of better vehicle as simply the product itself delivering stronger attributes for the customer, not what it costs or whether the company is turning a profit.

Semantics, I suppose.
 
I'd call that the more successful vehicle, not the better vehicle. I think of better vehicle as simply the product itself delivering stronger attributes for the customer, not what it costs or whether the company is turning a profit.

Semantics, I suppose.
Bragging rights don’t keep the lights on. I agree that Lucid is better than most other cars on the road. The problem is that not enough buyers agree with me. And the limited number that do aren’t enough to sustain the company.
 
Wrong. Everyone will care. Why? Because any Cosmos made in Saudi Arabia will be subject to import tariffs which will add probably $10,000-$15,000 to the price of a Cosmos. Ironically, a base Gravity made in the US at AMP-1 may be priced lower for US buyers.

Lucid has not publicly committed to EVER building the Cosmos at AMP-1 in the US. Until they publicly announce a timeline for tooling up AMP-1 to produce Cosmos (and Earth), all Cosmos will be produced in Saudi Arabia. After announcing tooling for AMP-1, figure on about another year before pilot production. I was really listening closely to the Q3 Earnings call, but Napoli and the rest of the speakers did NOT say anyghing about AMP-1 tooling for Cosmos. That worried me. It may never happen. We all assume that Cosmos will be produced and sold in the US eventually, but based upon what Lucid has SAID and what they have DONE, there is no plan to do so.
Of course they will go to GCC countries first ( as product test mules) and later to Europe. US is a bad place to sell EV’s.
 
I'm gonna push back on this a bit. Early Tesla build quality was spotty at best. Just like early Gravity build quality is spotty. Over several years of improvement in all aspects of car design and manufacture, Teslas built in the past 3 - 5 years are average or above in build quality. Same for actual driving experience. Now, having said that, Lucid is better on both fronts. Not bad for a brand that has only existed for less than 10 years. Teslas don't have to suck in order for Lucids to be better. We have one of each. Our 2023 Tesla Model Y is a very nice car. Our 2023 Lucid Air is way better.
But interior is cheap looking……not luxury feel. That us what I’m referring to.
 
Well I hope you're wrong. Because a $70K Cosmos would likely be the demise of the company. They simply don't have the balance sheet to support the sale of another low volume vehicle.
The argument that Cosmos is a better vehicle is the same rationale that hasn't resonated with either the Air or Gravity. The better vehicle will always be the one that sells and generates profits.
70 k will be top Trims. They said 48-50k for base.
 
Bragging rights don’t keep the lights on. I agree that Lucid is better than most other cars on the road. The problem is that not enough buyers agree with me. And the limited number that do aren’t enough to sustain the company.
Absolutely. Cosmos better be a successful product for the company or they're probably toast.
 
50k minimum over 10 years is essentially meaningless. That commitment won't help Lucid survive if Cosmos is not successful.

If Cosmos doesn't sell close to 50k in its first year of production alone then Lucid probably won't survive.
Disagree, 1st year production will be 10k? Those 10k may well go to those who don’t mind spending 70k. It’s a trickle down effect…..Rivuan base model isn’t coming out for another 6 months.
 
Of course they will go to GCC countries first ( as product test mules) and later to Europe. US is a bad place to sell EV’s.
Yes and no. Market share is lower here as a %, and we treat vehicles on a level playing field instead of subsidizing EVs now. BUT, even a small market share in the US is often a larger number of sales than a higher market share in a small country. Saudi Arabia has a smaller population than California. And our car ownership rate is significantly higher.
 
Back
Top