Cosmos incoming ……

Wrong. Everyone will care. Why? Because any Cosmos made in Saudi Arabia will be subject to import tariffs which will add probably $10,000-$15,000 to the price of a Cosmos. Ironically, a base Gravity made in the US at AMP-1 may be priced lower for US buyers.

Lucid has not publicly committed to EVER building the Cosmos at AMP-1 in the US. Until they publicly announce a timeline for tooling up AMP-1 to produce Cosmos (and Earth), all Cosmos will be produced in Saudi Arabia. After announcing tooling for AMP-1, figure on about another year before pilot production. I was really listening closely to the Q3 Earnings call, but Napoli and the rest of the speakers did NOT say anyghing about AMP-1 tooling for Cosmos. That worried me. It may never happen. We all assume that Cosmos will be produced and sold in the US eventually, but based upon what Lucid has SAID and what they have DONE, there is no plan to do so.
I mean consumer sentiment, if I were Lucid I wouldn't mention where its made, then people won't care.

I'm sure labor is cheaper.
 
Last edited:
Actually, Lucid would be wise to negotiate with the US and say something like, "Hey, let us get a waiver on the tariff for the first 50,000 Saudi built Cosmos and in return we (Lucid) will tool up AMP-1 immediately to move Cosmos production for the US market to AMP-1 in 2028." That may work.
That may be inevitable if they can't find a path to profitability for the current models. The great car giveaway can't go on forever.
 
I mean consumer sentiment, if I were Lucid I wouldn't mention where its made, then people won't care.

I'm sure labor is cheaper.
I would expect that every review will make mention of this. If for no other reason it's the first vehicle being built in the KSA and sold in the US so quality and reliability will be under the microscope. And Lucid's history of launching prior models will draw its own scrutiny. If the Air and Gravity had problem free launches it would probably just be a footnote. But they don't have that luxury.
 
Hmm some good points and consider all of the Americans saying ill not buy anything from China yet Walmart doesn’t seem to be hurting for sales.

And speaking of elon people are still buying his cars. So what people say vs what they do is, shall we say not always in alignment.
 
A Saudi build Cosmos will be too expensive to be competitive with a Tesla Model Y made in the US. Sad but simply economics.
I think if Lucid attempts to compete with Tesla on price, they will lose regardless.

Model Y will always be cheaper. And that’s okay. Toyotas are cheaper than BMWs. The target audience, at least for now, is less cost conscious folks.

Plenty of cars to be sold to people who are happy and able to spend $5-$10k more.

They can’t scale service fast enough to be selling more cars than Tesla, anyway.
 
all the speculation on sales and pricing is moot until we see the actual car - with features and looks being a massive factor in whether the market will like it or not. Example is the R2. On paper it’s really nothing special. But the style and brand image is driving strong sales.

If Lucid can create the right branding and nail the design, it won’t matter if it’s more than Model Y.
 
I think if Lucid attempts to compete with Tesla on price, they will lose regardless.

Model Y will always be cheaper. And that’s okay. Toyotas are cheaper than BMWs. The target audience, at least for now, is less cost conscious folks.

Plenty of cars to be sold to people who are happy and able to spend $5-$10k more.

They can’t scale service fast enough to be selling more cars than Tesla, anyway.
As price goes up the addressable market shrinks. For Lucid to succeed they need for the Cosmos to sell at volume. The Model Y is successful because it's aimed at the heart of the market where the majority of buyers are. Lucid needs to meet buyers where they are not where they want them to be. The Air and Gravity are aspirational vehicles. But not enough people aspire to own one. They can't afford to repeat that mistake with Cosmos.
 
The Saudi market is not going to demonstrate mass market demand. Only the US will do that. AMP-1 is only running at 20% capacity. So it would make sense to tool up and produce Cosmos at AMP-1. But they have committed to AMP-2 being the launch line for Cosmos.
Yes, but they will also be shipping to Europe
 
Yes, but they will also be shipping to Europe
The Saudi's are not just committed to building Cosmos but buying it as well. The same can't be said for the Europe or the US.

Per the 10-K:
Pursuant to the terms of the EV Purchase Agreement, the Government of Saudi Arabia and its entities and corporate subsidiaries and other beneficiaries (collectively, the“Purchaser”) may purchase up to 100,000 vehicles, with a minimum purchase quantity of 50,000 vehicles and an option to purchase up to an additional 50,000 vehicles during a ten-year period.

Obviously the US market is important, but the KSA has a lot more skin in the game. The decision to build Cosmos in the KSA is intertwined with the government's purchase agreement.
 
I think Tesla software is good but rest of the car is cheaply made, uninspiring interiors, poor ride and handling, lack of buttons is stupid. So we are never buying another Tesla. We prefer luxury interiors and a good drivers car.
I'm gonna push back on this a bit. Early Tesla build quality was spotty at best. Just like early Gravity build quality is spotty. Over several years of improvement in all aspects of car design and manufacture, Teslas built in the past 3 - 5 years are average or above in build quality. Same for actual driving experience. Now, having said that, Lucid is better on both fronts. Not bad for a brand that has only existed for less than 10 years. Teslas don't have to suck in order for Lucids to be better. We have one of each. Our 2023 Tesla Model Y is a very nice car. Our 2023 Lucid Air is way better.
 
Last edited:
So much talk in this thread about "they should do THIS instead of THAT". Fact of the matter is they have to do ALL of it.

Lucid needs to improve the vehicle service experience. They ARE doing that. They are investing in opening more service centers and increasing / improving staff at the ones that already exist. This is not INSTEAD of MARKETING it is in addition to.

Lucid needs to build a brand identity. Properties like the one that started this thread are a good start. Seeing this property should not lead anyone to believe that Lucid execs sat at a table and said "Ooo...ooo...ooo! I have an idea...instead of building a new service center why don't we make this marketing video". Car companies don't behave that way. I spent 38 years working in Engineering and also Product Portfolio Planning at a major automaker. Every function has its role. Just because one function's actions make it to the general press doesn't mean that the other functions are sitting on their hands or are sitting in the corner unfunded.

Lucid needs to improve the operation of the software and the app. There are identifiable indicators that they are doing just that. And it's not at the expense of / instead of improving the services center domain or building the brand name.

Any functional automaker has more than a CEO. They also have Chief Marketing Officers, Chief Customer Service Officers, Chief Technical Officers, and so on. I had the pleasure of meeting several of these officers at a customer meeting in Detroit a few months ago. Each has their own set of challenges to accomplish and budgets to support their doing so. When the CMO spends millions on a promotional piece it does not mean that the CCSO has to stop spending on opening and staffing service centers.

On one hand I believe that most people in this thread are reading what I just said and thinking "tell me something I didn't already know". But the back and forth about what Lucid needs to be focusing on and what is being ignored in favor of some other thing leads me to wonder if that is truly the case.
 
Last edited:
As price goes up the addressable market shrinks. For Lucid to succeed they need for the Cosmos to sell at volume. The Model Y is successful because it's aimed at the heart of the market where the majority of buyers are. Lucid needs to meet buyers where they are not where they want them to be. The Air and Gravity are aspirational vehicles. But not enough people aspire to own one. They can't afford to repeat that mistake with Cosmos.
There’s a massive difference between Gravity at $100k and Cosmos at $50k. That’s a 10x market size increase at least.

What I’m saying is Model Y at $35k is pointless to compete with. That’s not Lucid’s brand. Let Hyundai and Ford and Chevy fight over those customers.
 
Plenty of people spend $50k or more on their car. Lucid would have trouble keeping up with 5% of that market in the short term.
 
The best part about a $50-70k Cosmos range: it doesn’t outsell Model Y, but it robs Tesla of profit margin. It chips away at the fully loaded Model Ys, where all the money is.
 
There’s a massive difference between Gravity at $100k and Cosmos at $50k. That’s a 10x market size increase at least.

What I’m saying is Model Y at $35k is pointless to compete with. That’s not Lucid’s brand. Let Hyundai and Ford and Chevy fight over those customers.
The Model Y starts at $40K and the average selling price is $50K. So a $50K Cosmos would absolutely being competing with it. And I'm not saying that's a bad thing at all. If Lucid can offer a more compelling vehicle at that price point they'll be tapping into an established market with plenty of buyers. There are a lot of buyers looking for an alternative to Tesla.
 
The best part about a $50-70k Cosmos range: it doesn’t outsell Model Y, but it robs Tesla of profit margin. It chips away at the fully loaded Model Ys, where all the money is.
The Air Pure is in this price range and struggles to find buyers. And if Cosmos creeps up to $70K it will be competing with the heavily subsidized Gravity leases. And while that could be seen as a good way to move the Gravity, those deals only further exacerbate the company's losses. For the company to succeed it will need an appealing model, priced right, and sold at volume. And they'll need a sales and service organization to support it. And yes, the company will struggle in accomplishing that goal.
 
The Air Pure is in this price range and struggles to find buyers. And if Cosmos creeps up to $70K it will be competing with the heavily subsidized Gravity leases. And while that could be seen as a good way to move the Gravity, those deals only further exacerbate the company's losses. For the company to succeed it will need an appealing model, priced right, and sold at volume. And they'll need a sales and service organization to support it. And yes, the company will struggle in accomplishing that goal.
I expect subsidized Gravity leases to go away once Cosmos ships. Or shortly after, once they get inventory down.

Gravity and Air are always going to be low volume. I wouldn’t be surprised to see them both discontinued in the long term. Certainly the Air. It would cost more to update it at this point than they would likely make from the endeavor.
 
As price goes up the addressable market shrinks. For Lucid to succeed they need for the Cosmos to sell at volume. The Model Y is successful because it's aimed at the heart of the market where the majority of buyers are. Lucid needs to meet buyers where they are not where they want them to be. The Air and Gravity are aspirational vehicles. But not enough people aspire to own one. They can't afford to repeat that mistake with Cosmos.
Agreed. If the Cosmos arrives in the US $5,000 to $10,000 above similarly equipped Model Y, then Cosmos will fail to be the high volume car Lucid needs it to be for survival. For the Cosmos to succeed as the new option it needs to be priced on par with Model Y but be BETTER. That’s a tall order and it will never happen if they make Cosmos in Saudi Arabia annd import them to the US with shipping and tariff charges.
 
Last edited:
The Model Y starts at $40K and the average selling price is $50K. So a $50K Cosmos would absolutely being competing with it. And I'm not saying that's a bad thing at all. If Lucid can offer a more compelling vehicle at that price point they'll be tapping into an established market with plenty of buyers. There are a lot of buyers looking for an alternative to Tesla.
But a $50k Cosmos is barebones, while that’s a reasonably well equipped Model Y. The average Cosmos is likely going to be close to $70k, given how many people go for the $100k+ Air and Gravity models.

But yes. It’s the higher end folks getting the nicer Y that Lucid needs to focus on.
 
Agreed. If the Cosmos arrives in the US $5,000 to $10,000 above similarly equipped Model Y, then Cosmos will fail to be the high volume car Lucid needs it to be for survival. The Cosmos to succeed as the new option it needs to be priced on par with Model Y but be BETTER. That’s a tall order and it will never happen if they make Cosmos in Saudi Arabia in import them to the US with shipping and tariff charges.
I don't think they are aiming to compete with the Model Y. They may take some sales from the top end trims but that's not the main target.

They are aiming for the Volvo/BMW/MB mid-size Luxury SUV market. The model Y isn't really a luxury product.
 
Back
Top