OOS range tests the iX5 head to head against GGT and others

TahoeMichael

Active Member

Joined
Jul 13, 2023
Messages
1,540
Reaction score
2,579
Location
Tahoe City, CA
Cars
Toyota Highlander
Here's the video:


TL;DW summary:

70 mph drive-til-dead highway range test, all at the same time on the same highway.

iX5 went 410.8 miles at 2.8 m/kWh, consuming 148.2 kWh
GGT went 367.7 miles at 3.04 m/kWh, consuming 120.5 kWh
R1S went 348.9 miles at 2.59 m/kWh, consuming 136 kWh
Cayenne went 309.5 miles at 2.9 m/kWh, consuming 107 kWh

Regarding the GGT, the interesting thing to me is just how early the Gravity reads 0% charge: it had consumed 113.7 kWh after 346.4 miles. It didn't fail to maintain 70 mph until it had consumed 120.5 kWh. My personal preference would be that the vehicle accurately represent how much charge is left, and reporting 0% when it's really 5.6% just seems wrong. I know that there's been some discussion in the past about scenarios that make it hard to accurately capture how much power is in the battery, and so they very conservatively report 0% charge.
 
Here's the video:


TL;DW summary:

70 mph drive-til-dead highway range test, all at the same time on the same highway.

iX5 went 410.8 miles at 2.8 m/kWh, consuming 148.2 kWh
GGT went 367.7 miles at 3.04 m/kWh, consuming 120.5 kWh
R1S went 348.9 miles at 2.59 m/kWh, consuming 136 kWh
Cayenne went 309.5 miles at 2.9 m/kWh, consuming 107 kWh

Regarding the GGT, the interesting thing to me is just how early the Gravity reads 0% charge: it had consumed 113.7 kWh after 346.4 miles. It didn't fail to maintain 70 mph until it had consumed 120.5 kWh. My personal preference would be that the vehicle accurately represent how much charge is left, and reporting 0% when it's really 5.6% just seems wrong. I know that there's been some discussion in the past about scenarios that make it hard to accurately capture how much power is in the battery, and so they very conservatively report 0% charge.
Do you also have the data from the manufacturers as to what are their claimed ranges? To the extent they cited EPA numbers, keep in mind there are different EPA cycle tests and how the manufacturers report their numbers.
 
Do you also have the data from the manufacturers as to what are their claimed ranges? To the extent they cited EPA numbers, keep in mind there are different EPA cycle tests and how the manufacturers report their numbers.
I presume the R1S did not use "Conserve" mode in this test, correct?
 
...70 mph drive-til-dead highway range test, all at the same time on the same highway.

iX5 went 410.8 miles at 2.8 m/kWh, consuming 148.2 kWh
GGT went 367.7 miles at 3.04 m/kWh, consuming 120.5 kWh
R1S went 348.9 miles at 2.59 m/kWh, consuming 136 kWh
Cayenne went 309.5 miles at 2.9 m/kWh, consuming 107 kWh
So Gravity IS more efficient than it competitors, good news. It just needs a bigger battery to catch the iX5.
 
Last edited:
So Gravity IS more efficient, good news. It just needs a bigger battery to catch the iX5.

That’s kinda how I see it too - bigger battery goes further. That isn’t necessarily an engineering breakthrough. The Escalade IQ goes a long way too with twice the battery.
 
That’s kinda how I see it too - bigger battery goes further. That isn’t necessarily an engineering breakthrough. The Escalade IQ goes a long way too with twice the battery.
But the Escalade's efficiency is horrible, worse than any in this test. Those miles will cost you, at least in California. Not so much in regions with plentiful hydro power.
 
So Gravity IS more efficient than it competitors, good news. It just needs a bigger battery to catch the iX5.
But there is a fine balance. More battery = more weight = LESS efficiency.
That’s kinda how I see it too - bigger battery goes further. That isn’t necessarily an engineering breakthrough. The Escalade IQ goes a long way too with twice the battery.
Exhibit A ☝️☝️
 
So Gravity IS more efficient, good news. It just needs a bigger battery to catch the iX5.
That's true. But, if you look at the efficiency metrics, in (this) real-life 70mph test, the iX5 and the Cayenne are only 5% and 8% in efficiency behind the GGT, not the 20+ % advantages one might infer by comparing the raw EPA numbers. The R1S is about 15% (efficiency) behind the GGT. I don't think the R1S was operated in "Conserve" mode. If so, the R1S might pick up another 7-10% efficiency.

Lucid is still the most efficient EV amongst the bunch. But, as I pointed out before, if you transcend the fog of the quoted efficiency/range numbers quoted by the various EV manufacturers, Lucid is still amongst the most efficient, but only by small amount!
 
... I don't think the R1S was operated in "Conserve" mode. If so, the R1S might pick up another 7-10% efficiency.
You're right about the Rivian's drive mode. Gemini said:
"For the highway range test, the drivers configured each vehicle to prioritize efficiency while maintaining a 70 mph cruise speed. Here are the specific modes and settings used for each vehicle:
  • Lucid Gravity Grand Touring: The car was set to Smooth mode (0:27:26) with the ride height manually forced to Low and the Auto ride height setting deselected (0:27:25).
  • Porsche Cayenne Turbo Electric: The vehicle was set to Normal mode for the drivetrain. The chassis was set to Normal, but the suspension level was set to Low to improve aerodynamic efficiency (0:18:35-0:18:42).
  • BMW iX5: The driver configured the vehicle to Efficient mode (0:19:46), which includes an "eco AC" setting (0:19:48). The powertrain was set to Eco, and the energy recovery system was set to Adaptive (0:20:51). The chassis and steering remained in Comfort (0:20:54).
  • Rivian R1S: As previously noted, this vehicle was set to All-Purpose mode (0:24:45), with the Auto ride height deselected, the suspension locked in Low, and the ride feel set to Moderate (0:24:52)."
 
So Gravity IS more efficient than it competitors, good news. It just needs a bigger battery to catch the iX5.
Peter used to call that "Dumb Range"
 
You're right about the Rivian's drive mode. Gemini said:
"For the highway range test, the drivers configured each vehicle to prioritize efficiency while maintaining a 70 mph cruise speed. Here are the specific modes and settings used for each vehicle:
  • Lucid Gravity Grand Touring: The car was set to Smooth mode (0:27:26) with the ride height manually forced to Low and the Auto ride height setting deselected (0:27:25).
  • Porsche Cayenne Turbo Electric: The vehicle was set to Normal mode for the drivetrain. The chassis was set to Normal, but the suspension level was set to Low to improve aerodynamic efficiency (0:18:35-0:18:42).
  • BMW iX5: The driver configured the vehicle to Efficient mode (0:19:46), which includes an "eco AC" setting (0:19:48). The powertrain was set to Eco, and the energy recovery system was set to Adaptive (0:20:51). The chassis and steering remained in Comfort (0:20:54).
  • Rivian R1S: As previously noted, this vehicle was set to All-Purpose mode (0:24:45), with the Auto ride height deselected, the suspension locked in Low, and the ride feel set to Moderate (0:24:52)."
Thank you for summarizing the key points! Very succinct and helpful.

I don't have the patience to sit through Kyle's hours-long reviews. He has to do these log reviews to pay his bills!
 
Thank you for summarizing the key points! Very succinct and helpful.

I don't have the patience to sit through Kyle's hours-long reviews. He has to do these log reviews to pay his bills!
I let Gemini do it. Just clicked on the little Gemini star in the lower right corner below the video and then typed in the question.
 
I let Gemini do it. Just clicked on the little Gemini star in the lower right corner below the video and then typed in the question.
Ahhh, Gemini vs Kyle Connor! ;)
 
FWIW, the Gravity was also in Low, not Lowest, height, so it too may have picked up a bit of efficiency, though I do not know how much.
 
Peter used to call that "Dumb Range"
Yes, the iX5 has 12% greater range with 8% lower efficiency. I'd take that tradeoff while driving in the desert.
 
There needs to be a market study to find customer preferences... to see which aspect buyers care more about. Just my hunch that the vast majority of EV buyers will prioritize range over efficiency. And by how much. Everything is a tradeoff but I'm guessing buyers would take 10% more range over 10% less efficiency. If there's a study out already, I'd like to see it.
 
There needs to be a market study to find customer preferences... to see which aspect buyers care more about. Just my hunch that the vast majority of EV buyers will prioritize range over efficiency. And by how much. Everything is a tradeoff but I'm guessing buyers would take 10% more range over 10% less efficiency. If there's a study out already, I'd like to see it.
And by how much. Double efficiency? That’s cool. 8% better?…..oh
 
And by how much. Double efficiency? That’s cool. 8% better?…..oh
Yeah, efficiency, by itself, is an incomplete argument. The "Figure-of-Merit" has to be a balance between efficiency, range, cost of ownership (lease vs buy-depreciation), and the type of driving you do (city vs long road trips, roundtrips in area where there is an abundance of EV charging stations, or not), etc..

As we get more into the $45k to $55k price range (e.g., Cosmos, R2S, etc.,) Service, and location of Service Centers figure prominantly in the decision process.

Lucid has some good building blocks in their power train/efficiency. As the recent OoS comparison shows, their efficiency leadership is single-digit percentage, not the 20%+ advantage as suggested by the bastardized EPA cycles/fudge-factors. Lucid's claims of efficiency and range is not as robust as the advertisements. Service and price of acquisition will be much more important.

In the next couple of years, there is not enough time or money for Lucid to build enough service centers to address these gaps. Lucid needs to think partnership with establish service providers (e.g., Discount Tires etc.) to bootstrap their business model.
 
Back
Top