Cosmos incoming ……

I don't think they are aiming to compete with the Model Y. They may take some sales from the top end trims but that's not the main target.

They are aiming for the Volvo/BMW/MB mid-size Luxury SUV market. The model Y isn't really a luxury product.
IMHO there are no vehicles where Tesla and luxury are both used to describe a product of any kind.
 
I love this forum! I truly do!

14 of the 19 (so far) posts on this page (not including quotations and replies) use the word "if".

The beautiful part of this page is all of our strong predictions or suggestions for the future. Coming from the financial world, virtually NONE of these will come true for the reasons being given.

Maybe Lucid will make it, maybe not. Maybe it will be insufficient sales from poor marketing or poor word of mouth from service issues. Maybe they'll produce 40K cars in a year, but will lose money on each one, putting them out of business. Maybe they'll be taken private or absorbed by another company or maybe they'll grow and become a robust manufacturer in a declining number of world-wide automobile manufacturers.

The fun part - look at the overall stock market and how it operates - is that ANYTHING can disrupt the future. If the Lyon Township, MI data center is not built, will that change the world? Probably not. However, it WILL take business from local electricians and plumbers and concrete workers, who invest in the SP500 through IRAs and their 401(k). Remember, “A butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can set off a tornado in Texas.”

My meandering point is that we can prognosticate all we want, however Lucid's future is predicated on kazillions (my own estimate) of things going right and another kazillion things NOT going wrong.

We're all arm chair quarterbacks of the C-Suite, with a fabulous depth of experience and expertise in a multitude of fields. Let's hope Mr. Napoli and company have the in-depth knowledge and ability to make more right decisions and less wrong decisions - I want to buy Gravity Gen 2 to replace my current Gravity and that will only happen if a couple kazillion things move in the company's favor.

Here's to Lucid's success in navigating the unknown!

Have a great weekend and Dream Ahead!!
 
And… twice as many customers to share their amazing experiences.

Seriously, I do get your point.
Don't have to be a customer to share experiences. I only know a handful of people who have ever owned a Ferrari and only one that has owned a McLaren. But if you were to peak at my bucket list...
 
I love this forum! I truly do!

14 of the 19 (so far) posts on this page (not including quotations and replies) use the word "if".

The beautiful part of this page is all of our strong predictions or suggestions for the future. Coming from the financial world, virtually NONE of these will come true for the reasons being given.

Maybe Lucid will make it, maybe not. Maybe it will be insufficient sales from poor marketing or poor word of mouth from service issues. Maybe they'll produce 40K cars in a year, but will lose money on each one, putting them out of business. Maybe they'll be taken private or absorbed by another company or maybe they'll grow and become a robust manufacturer in a declining number of world-wide automobile manufacturers.

The fun part - look at the overall stock market and how it operates - is that ANYTHING can disrupt the future. If the Lyon Township, MI data center is not built, will that change the world? Probably not. However, it WILL take business from local electricians and plumbers and concrete workers, who invest in the SP500 through IRAs and their 401(k). Remember, “A butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can set off a tornado in Texas.”

My meandering point is that we can prognosticate all we want, however Lucid's future is predicated on kazillions (my own estimate) of things going right and another kazillion things NOT going wrong.

We're all arm chair quarterbacks of the C-Suite, with a fabulous depth of experience and expertise in a multitude of fields. Let's hope Mr. Napoli and company have the in-depth knowledge and ability to make more right decisions and less wrong decisions - I want to buy Gravity Gen 2 to replace my current Gravity and that will only happen if a couple kazillion things move in the company's favor.

Here's to Lucid's success in navigating the unknown!

Have a great weekend and Dream Ahead!!
The most frequent words I say at work are "Probably", "Maybe", "If", "Likely", and "Could"

Drives the business leads crazy 🤣
 
I like the way you think but I am gonna push back on a couple things. Doesn't mean you are not right...means there are other considerations.
Also, auto sales is pretty much a zero sum game. It's just not one that a single company can win. When brands rise, they take from their competitors. Just look at the Chinese auto market and what EV sales have done to European brands. Honda and Toyota took the entire sedan market from American companies decades ago, and now Hyundai wants to take from them. But the sedan market is also being destroyed by SUVs in general, not just in the US but across the world. Those same American companies don't want the Toyota Tundra to do well because they don't want their cash cow pickups to be slaughtered. Lucid and Rivian want to do the same thing to established brands. If they don't take enough sales from those brands then they'll go bankrupt.

This is a little bit of nitpicking on my part, but I'm gonna go there. GM, Ford, and to a lesser degree FCA (before Stellantis) pretty much handed the sedan segments to Honda, Toyota, and Hyundai-Kia. Think back to the '80s when every brand had one or two minivans in their portfolio. Then, seemingly overnight, everybody except Chrysler, Honda, and Toyota walked away from the minivan market. Those that were left had large slices of a much smaller pie. Similarly, GM, Ford, and FCA intentionally left the sedan segment based on rapidly slowing sales in the segment plus very strangely scripted fuel economy regulations. The shrinkage of the sedan market is something I participated in as a Product Portfolio Planning executive at a major automaker and as a consultant after I retired from the automaker. It's a fascinating case study. One of the reasons I even own an Air is that I can see the potential for a sedan revival based on the fuel economy aspect of sedans being irrelevant for EVs.

You can see this playing out in the Chinese market at a much faster pace. New EV brands need every sale they can get so they can survive longer than other new brands. Some of them have already failed. Now the survivors want to export across the world as Chinese domestic sales flag which no country with an automotive industry wants because they're afraid those cheap EVs will destroy manufacturing jobs as sales drop. Countries with no automotive industry don't have that incentive. We're going to see the big global car companies like Toyota and VW show declining sales by small amounts as cheap Chinese cars flood those small markets.

Absolutely. This is already happening in Europe, South America and Mexico (which SHOULD HAVE been protected by US manufacturers. I'll stop there. The rest is very political. ) Africa is next. You may have heard of Africa. HUGE continent. Lots of people. Untapped car market. Not as backward as many of us have grown up believing and not just full of $#!t#0l3 countries as characterized by someone.

This is a crazy statement. For the three largest car markets in the world, the US is first with an average new car sales price at $50k. Europe as a whole is at $39k. China is $23k. An average sales price of $70k absolutely reduces your customer base by a lot. Can Lucid survive off a smaller base? Maybe. But it's telling that even the traditional luxury brands have always moved down market in search of more revenue/profit. And you can always look at global sales figures by brand. You have to go down to 12th place to find a brand that is a traditional luxury name, BMW.
I'm assuming your ranking of the three largest markets is ranked by average price, not actual market size. If by market size, China is first, Europe second, North America third. There are some significant nuances to the US market. One is the energizer bunny behavior of the pickup truck and large SUV market. Unique in size and scope to the US. Not just North America, but specifically the US. A lot of the high average price position is due to the proliferation of product in the pickup truck and large SUV market segments. Some of the attractiveness of the large SUV market is being actively pushed down to midsized and luxury midsized SUV segments. These segments are also serving to push the average price upward. This is where Lucid and Rivian are looking to play and where Tesla has strangely chosen to walk away from. Cadillac and Mercedes-Benz are more than happy to step into that void, each with multiple luxury midsize and compact SUVs. Then the final US-focused nuance...72 month and 84 month financing. It's here. When dealing with a customer population that is in many cases more focused on the monthly payment than the number at the bottom of the contract, leasing and 6 - 7 year financing makes $70 - 100k vehicles a lot more accessible.
 
Last edited:
IMHO there are no vehicles where Tesla and luxury are both used to describe a product of any kind.
This was a huge conundrum in my last few years in Product Portfolio Planning at a major OEM. Tesla was placed in the Luxury category by all of the major forecasting and analysis house based primarily on the aspects of price and the determination that quiet electric propulsion could be viewed as a luxury. Another way to look at this, and it was not lost on US automotive analysts, self included... When Tesla launched the Model S it took sales primarily from Mercedes-Benz S-Class, E-Class and BMW 5-Series. When Tesla launched Model X it took sales primarily from BMW X5 and X6 and Mercedes-Benz GLS and GLE. For a vehicle that may or may not have been considered luxurious in content, it sure beat the crap out of some top-tier luxury competitors. Enough so that both BMW and Mercedes-Benz quickly launched aggressive EV product development divisions. That doesn't happen for non-luxury competitors.
 
No problem selling because they are cheaper than Garavity/Air, more service availability stable software. It’s not a reflection of product interior being luxurious. Their sales have actually peaked.
Yeah I would argue how good the Model Y is they should be selling 3x more of them, yet that would still leave TSLA 60-70% below those old sales targets they claimed...
 
I love this forum! I truly do!

14 of the 19 (so far) posts on this page (not including quotations and replies) use the word "if".

The beautiful part of this page is all of our strong predictions or suggestions for the future. Coming from the financial world, virtually NONE of these will come true for the reasons being given.

Maybe Lucid will make it, maybe not. Maybe it will be insufficient sales from poor marketing or poor word of mouth from service issues. Maybe they'll produce 40K cars in a year, but will lose money on each one, putting them out of business. Maybe they'll be taken private or absorbed by another company or maybe they'll grow and become a robust manufacturer in a declining number of world-wide automobile manufacturers.

The fun part - look at the overall stock market and how it operates - is that ANYTHING can disrupt the future. If the Lyon Township, MI data center is not built, will that change the world? Probably not. However, it WILL take business from local electricians and plumbers and concrete workers, who invest in the SP500 through IRAs and their 401(k). Remember, “A butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can set off a tornado in Texas.”

My meandering point is that we can prognosticate all we want, however Lucid's future is predicated on kazillions (my own estimate) of things going right and another kazillion things NOT going wrong.

We're all arm chair quarterbacks of the C-Suite, with a fabulous depth of experience and expertise in a multitude of fields. Let's hope Mr. Napoli and company have the in-depth knowledge and ability to make more right decisions and less wrong decisions - I want to buy Gravity Gen 2 to replace my current Gravity and that will only happen if a couple kazillion things move in the company's favor.

Here's to Lucid's success in navigating the unknown!

Have a great weekend and Dream Ahead!!
 
This was a huge conundrum in my last few years in Product Portfolio Planning at a major OEM. Tesla was placed in the Luxury category by all of the major forecasting and analysis house based primarily on the aspects of price and the determination that quiet electric propulsion could be viewed as a luxury. Another way to look at this, and it was not lost on US automotive analysts, self included... When Tesla launched the Model S it took sales primarily from Mercedes-Benz S-Class, E-Class and BMW 5-Series. When Tesla launched Model X it took sales primarily from BMW X5 and X6 and Mercedes-Benz GLS and GLE. For a vehicle that may or may not have been considered luxurious in content, it sure beat the crap out of some top-tier luxury competitors. Enough so that both BMW and Mercedes-Benz quickly launched aggressive EV product development divisions. That doesn't happen for non-luxury competitors.
They were at the time a luxury product, the brand name was aspirational, and the product was incredibly sophisticated with tech and design compared to the existing competition, and they had superior driving characteristics in acceleration, smoothness even though the ride and build quality was bad. Now every Chinese car drives like a BMW or Tesla. The non-luxury car companies correctly hedged that the technology would not get cheap or reliable enough to threaten their gas and hybrid lineups and has largely been correct until recently.
 
They were at the time a luxury product, the brand name was aspirational, and the product was incredibly sophisticated with tech and design compared to the existing competition, and they had superior driving characteristics in acceleration, smoothness even though the ride and build quality was bad. Now every Chinese car drives like a BMW or Tesla. The non-luxury car companies correctly hedged that the technology would not get cheap or reliable enough to threaten their gas and hybrid lineups and has largely been correct until recently.
Yup. Model 3 and Model Y further muddied the waters. While argument could be made for Model S and X to be considered luxury nameplates, it was hard to continue to consider Tesla as a luxury brand given that the majority of their product offerings by volume were now firmly planted in mainstream segments.
 
This was a huge conundrum in my last few years in Product Portfolio Planning at a major OEM. Tesla was placed in the Luxury category by all of the major forecasting and analysis house based primarily on the aspects of price and the determination that quiet electric propulsion could be viewed as a luxury. Another way to look at this, and it was not lost on US automotive analysts, self included... When Tesla launched the Model S it took sales primarily from Mercedes-Benz S-Class, E-Class and BMW 5-Series. When Tesla launched Model X it took sales primarily from BMW X5 and X6 and Mercedes-Benz GLS and GLE. For a vehicle that may or may not have been considered luxurious in content, it sure beat the crap out of some top-tier luxury competitors. Enough so that both BMW and Mercedes-Benz quickly launched aggressive EV product development divisions. That doesn't happen for non-luxury competitors.
I really appreciate your insights. It shows us that a lot of these traditional labels around topics are constantly evolving. And for automakers it all comes down to sales. Doesn’t matter what label you attach to a vehicle, it has to find its way into the hands of a buyer.
 
One of the reasons I even own an Air is that I can see the potential for a sedan revival based on the fuel economy aspect of sedans being irrelevant for EVs.
I definitely agree, and I base that on listening to my 14yr old niece and her friends talk.
They want CARS, not SUVs like mom 'n dad have.
They want small/midsize "nice" car with basic creature comforts and a "good" stereo that is economical on gas (maybe electric if it's good enough by then)(quote).
As GenAlpha ages into the driving world, I too, think there will be a resurgence in car demand.
And whatever company is offering them, be it Toyota, Honda, Hyunda, or some Chinese brands, that's who they'll go to.
They won't give GM, Ford or Chrys-lantis a single look, because they have nothing to offer what they want.
 
Currently in France and have gotten Ubers in Teslas, a M3 & MY, and a BYD Seal, Tesla should be afraid, very afraid. All future Lucids need to be darn perfect on launch and remain that way.

IMHO you can’t reliably produce anything where the inexpensive versions look similar to the expensive ones. Eg a 40$ car and a 100$ car should not look alike, unless you really don’t want to kill the sales of the expensive one.

Anybody remember the fantastic sales volume of the VW Phaeton? Yeah didn’t think so.
 
I definitely agree, and I base that on listening to my 14yr old niece and her friends talk.
They want CARS, not SUVs like mom 'n dad have.
They want small/midsize "nice" car with basic creature comforts and a "good" stereo that is economical on gas (maybe electric if it's good enough by then)(quote).
As GenAlpha ages into the driving world, I too, think there will be a resurgence in car demand.
And whatever company is offering them, be it Toyota, Honda, Hyunda, or some Chinese brands, that's who they'll go to.
They won't give GM, Ford or Chrys-lantis a single look, because they have nothing to offer what they want.
People don't understand how ubiquitous and uncool big expensive SUVs are to the younger generations yet....
 
People don't understand how ubiquitous and uncool big expensive SUVs are to the younger generations yet....
About as ubiquitous and uncool as minivans used to be to the prior generation. But at some point the younger generation is going to be hauling their own kids and making trips to the Home Depot.
 
I delivered a mini-split (two interior, one exterior unit) all wiring, tools and plumbing needed for installation in a compact hatchback. You do what you have to.
As for lumber, never used a sun roof, but did move 2 12ft 2x8's a short distance (8 miles) in a sedan. Diagonally from rear trunk corner, out front passenger window.
 
They can get off my lawn tho
1795201009479.webp
They're not on your lawn. They're inside on their phones, talking to eachother on facetime.
About as ubiquitous and uncool as minivans used to be to the prior generation. But at some point the younger generation is going to be hauling their own kids and making trips to the Home Depot.
True, but that's like 20yrs away. The execs at car companies right now, won't even be around then.
And if the high practicality of GenAlpha continues, and they have their own kids, they'll likely get that SUV to haul everyone around in.
I bet they get the base models though.
 
Back
Top