OOS range tests the iX5 head to head against GGT and others

In the next couple of years, there is not enough time or money for Lucid to build enough service centers to address these gaps. Lucid needs to think partnership with establish service providers (e.g., Discount Tires etc.) to bootstrap their business model.
I'm not sure how much Discount Tires would alleviate service center issues. At the end of the day they just sell tires and there's nothing preventing a Lucid owner from getting tires there. Many owners already do. And they don't seem to be chomping at the bit to get into the business of installing window regulators or replacing drive motors nor do any of their competitors.
 
I'm not sure how much Discount Tires would alleviate service center issues. At the end of the day they just sell tires and there's nothing preventing a Lucid owner from getting tires there. Many owners already do. And they don't seem to be chomping at the bit to get into the business of installing window regulators or replacing drive motors nor do any of their competitors.
I know the bodyshop investment is something like $80k to repair a Lucid, I don't know what it would be to certify a repair or service location. I'd like to think they are working that out in the EU market a bit with new distribution model they're working over there.
 
A simplified consumer perspective:

All the numbers and geeking out aside, my entry into EV ownership really hinged on having ~350 mile real world range (roughly equivalent to a full tank of gas in my mind) in a dynamic but family-friendly package (replaced my ND Miata lol). Surprisingly, very few vehicles met and meet this test.

To me, again offering a simplified perspective, this latest video shows that the real-world range moat has shrunken considerably since the Gravity was launched, and with increasing competition from established brands like BMW, I may no longer have to accept or otherwise make concessions for service availability or initial build quality come lease renewal to get such a package (at least, that is the hope).
 
I'm not sure how much Discount Tires would alleviate service center issues. At the end of the day they just sell tires and there's nothing preventing a Lucid owner from getting tires there. Many owners already do. And they don't seem to be chomping at the bit to get into the business of installing window regulators or replacing drive motors nor do any of their competitors
Exactly my point.....Lucid SC tried to get you do tires, alignment, 12V battery, fluid fills, etc.. They CAN'T AFFORD to do that stuff!

Focus ONLY on services Lucid must do!
 
There needs to be a market study to find customer preferences... to see which aspect buyers care more about. Just my hunch that the vast majority of EV buyers will prioritize range over efficiency. And by how much. Everything is a tradeoff but I'm guessing buyers would take 10% more range over 10% less efficiency. If there's a study out already, I'd like to see it.

Well, what does every EV maker advertise - range or efficiency? That tells you that most people just want range and don’t care to get into the math of how efficient these are. They just want to drive the furthest without range anxiety and the least number of stops to charge.
 
But there is a fine balance. More battery = more weight = LESS efficiency.

Exhibit A ☝️☝️

Agreed - that 9000 lb monstrosity is the opposite of what EVs should strive to solve for in general.
 
Exactly my point.....Lucid SC tried to get you do tires, alignment, 12V battery, fluid fills, etc.. They CAN'T AFFORD to do that stuff!

Focus ONLY on services Lucid must do!
I'm not seeing a lot of owners venting over their inability to get tires for their Lucid. And to the extent they are, other owners are already steering them to Discount Tire, Costco, etc.

The backlog at service centers is being driven by issues that only Lucid can remedy. Your suggestion that things would be different but for tires and alignments is a bit misguided.
 
I'm not seeing a lot of owners venting over their inability to get tires for their Lucid. And to the extent they are, other owners are already steering them to Discount Tire, Costco, etc.

The backlog at service centers is being driven by issues that only Lucid can remedy. You're suggesting that things would be different but for tires and alignments is a bit misguided.
Not true. On my last service appointment at the Scottsdale SC, they asked me to do alignment.

Look, the Lucid SC is a P&L unto itself.

In contrast, my Rivian SC told me to take my R1S to Discount Tires to do all the mundane stuff. And Discount Tire did a fantastic job, no appointments.

Separately, some forum owners that needs body work complained about the excessive wait time (months) to get Lucid parts. A few months ago, my Rivian R1S, parked outside of Micro Center in Phoenix, was side swiped by an unknown car. Three panel has to be replaced. Rivian has 4 authorized body shops on the Phoenix area (6, if you counter the greater Phoenix area). The body shop quoted me "up to 2 weeks" to get it done. They were done in 4 days. Lucid body parts are constantly in short supply. The wait can be months!

These kind of (lack-of) supply infrastructure will kill Lucid if they don't pay attention to it! Buyers of Cosmos won't put up with it!
 
Exactly my point.....Lucid SC tried to get you do tires, alignment, 12V battery, fluid fills, etc.. They CAN'T AFFORD to do that stuff!

Focus ONLY on services Lucid must do!
Except owners can already take their cars to any 3rd party shop for that kind of simple stuff. Those are non-warranty consumable items, so there's no reason to go through (much more difficult) Lucid for that. We just drive it over to Discount Tire and we're in and out in 90 minutes.

What owners need/want is a better experience for fixing Lucid-specific problems and issues. Software... seats... fobs... windows... climate control... body... etc.
 
Not true. On my last service appointment at the Scottsdale SC, they asked me to do alignment.

Look, the Lucid SC is a P&L unto itself.

In contrast, my Rivian SC told me to take my R1S to Discount Tires to do all the mundane stuff. And Discount Tire did a fantastic job, no appointments.

Separately, some forum owners that needs body work complained about the excessive wait time (months) to get Lucid parts. A few months ago, my Rivian R1S, parked outside of Micro Center in Phoenix, was side swiped by an unknown car. Three panel has to be replaced. Rivian has 4 authorized body shops on the Phoenix area (6, if you counter the greater Phoenix area). The body shop quoted me "up to 2 weeks" to get it done. They were done in 4 days. Lucid body parts are constantly in short supply. The wait can be months!

These kind of (lack-of) supply infrastructure will kill Lucid if they don't pay attention to it! Buyers of Cosmos won't put up with it!
Again, no owner is prevented from using Discount Tire. The mere fact that Rivian is suggesting it while Lucid doesn't likely factor into the service backlog. I would agree with your point on body shops but that's moving the goal posts.
 
Except owners can already take their cars to any 3rd party shop for that kind of simple stuff. Those are non-warranty consumable items, so there's no reason to go through (much more difficult) Lucid for that. We just drive it over to Discount Tire and we're in and out in 90 minutes.

What owners need/want is a better experience for fixing Lucid-specific problems and issues. Software... seats... fobs... windows... climate control... body... etc.
And Lucid Management should DIRECT their SCs NOT to do the mundane stuff Discount Tire can do. Just tell the customers to go to Discount Tires and get it done. Rivian SC LITERALLY told me they don't do that stuff anymore.

That's the kind of leadership/strategic thinking Lucid management needs. They can't get to SC stability unless they take strong actions!
 
And Lucid Management should DIRECT their SCs NOT to do the mundane stuff Discount Tire can do. Just tell the customers to go to Discount Tires and get it done. Rivian SC LITERALLY told me they don't do that stuff anymore.

That's the kind of leadership/strategic thinking Lucid management needs. They can't get to SC stability unless they take strong actions!
I'm fine with that, although I guess we could make the case that IF a customer is also having something else done that only Lucid can do, that they still do it so that the customer doesn't have to take it to 2 different places (or Lucid adds a day and takes it to Discount Tire themselves).

But yes, if ALL they're having done is stuff that's far more easily done at DT (and for probably half the price), then by all means, do that. And even recommend people do that.
 
I'm fine with that, although I guess we could make the case that IF a customer is also having something else done that only Lucid can do, that they still do it so that the customer doesn't have to take it to 2 different places (or Lucid adds a day and takes it to Discount Tire themselves).

But yes, if ALL they're having done is stuff that's far more easily done at DT (and for probably half the price), then by all means, do that. And even recommend people do that.
DT does not charge for tire rotations and tire repairs. I think they charge for wheel alignment.

Discount Tires love doing it....it is an incentive for you to go to DT when you need to buy new tires. They play the long game!

Costco is not nearly as friendly. The last time I tried to get my tires looked at Costco, they won't do it. They said they didn't have the lift pucks, and they don't like working on Lucids (Air) because of its clearance. Maybe it is just my Costco. Or maybe it was me?! 😢
 
A simplified consumer perspective:

All the numbers and geeking out aside, my entry into EV ownership really hinged on having ~350 mile real world range (roughly equivalent to a full tank of gas in my mind) in a dynamic but family-friendly package (replaced my ND Miata lol). Surprisingly, very few vehicles met and meet this test.

To me, again offering a simplified perspective, this latest video shows that the real-world range moat has shrunken considerably since the Gravity was launched, and with increasing competition from established brands like BMW, I may no longer have to accept or otherwise make concessions for service availability or initial build quality come lease renewal to get such a package (at least, that is the hope).
Agreed. Range is still one of the biggest criteria for many buyers, especially EV newbies. But not just them. This is my 3rd EV and super range was one of my prerequisites. It's what got me to consider the Gravity in the first place. Granted, I'm in a less common situation where road trips are almost 80% of my total miles. We're on the road a lot, doing 2500+ mile road trips every other month. Most of it through wide-open western states with some big DCFC gaps. But still, even a 6-year EV veteran like me values big range. Newbies that are less confident in the EV charging landscape are even more likely to want long range. It's a big selling point.

If the iX5 were available last year, I'd have considered it. Might have even chosen it over the Gravity. Lots of pros and cons to both. More service centers and a company that's far more likely to still be in business through the life of my ownership is a big plus. But the extra space and storage in the Gravity is big, and I love the squirkle and large display over the dash. But the fob is still super annoying (finally got a service appt for Dec 1 to check it out). Etc etc etc.

I'm locked into the Gravity now (purchased it) so it's all moot, but it would have been an interesting competition.
 
Interesting comparison. Not sure how prices compare, but they are all impressive. FWIW, I visited a large BMW dealer but they did not have any iX5's and did not know when they would get any. (My 2025 AGT was totaled on Oct 29 by my insurance company.) I was considering alternatives to the GGT and aside from objective values of range and battery size the decision includes more variables for me. To me there are no viable alternatives to Lucid in what is inevitably a subjective decision. The design elements of the GGT to me are worlds better than the others. I also drove a Macan GTS EV, which is derived from a ten year old Macan. Impressive dynamically as I expected but its design did not move me at all, and I have been a lifelong Porsche fan and multiple model owner. The qualitative aspects of a vehicle are important at these price points and range and efficiency should be a given.
 
Well, what does every EV maker advertise - range or efficiency? That tells you that most people just want range and don’t care to get into the math of how efficient these are. They just want to drive the furthest without range anxiety and the least number of stops to charge.
That's my point. Stop advertising the efficiency claims and wrong range claims.

Better to under promise and over deliver. Unfortunately Lucid is in this position because of the opposite.

I'm optimistic this new leadership will finally address all the gaps. Service, reliability, sales experience, supple chain, etc. They've got a lot of work ahead.
 
Interesting comparison. Not sure how prices compare, but they are all impressive. FWIW, I visited a large BMW dealer but they did not have any iX5's and did not know when they would get any. (My 2025 AGT was totaled on Oct 29 by my insurance company.) I was considering alternatives to the GGT and aside from objective values of range and battery size the decision includes more variables for me. To me there are no viable alternatives to Lucid in what is inevitably a subjective decision. The design elements of the GGT to me are worlds better than the others. I also drove a Macan GTS EV, which is derived from a ten year old Macan. Impressive dynamically as I expected but its design did not move me at all, and I have been a lifelong Porsche fan and multiple model owner. The qualitative aspects of a vehicle are important at these price points and range and efficiency should be a given.
I don't think there will be any iX5's delivered to customers in the USA until well into next year. OOS gets early access as part of BMW's effort to promote the vehicle. And presumably the first few months of deliveries will be to people willing to pre-order without ever having had a chance to test drive.
 
Here's the video:


TL;DW summary:

70 mph drive-til-dead highway range test, all at the same time on the same highway.

iX5 went 410.8 miles at 2.8 m/kWh, consuming 148.2 kWh
GGT went 367.7 miles at 3.04 m/kWh, consuming 120.5 kWh
R1S went 348.9 miles at 2.59 m/kWh, consuming 136 kWh
Cayenne went 309.5 miles at 2.9 m/kWh, consuming 107 kWh

Regarding the GGT, the interesting thing to me is just how early the Gravity reads 0% charge: it had consumed 113.7 kWh after 346.4 miles. It didn't fail to maintain 70 mph until it had consumed 120.5 kWh. My personal preference would be that the vehicle accurately represent how much charge is left, and reporting 0% when it's really 5.6% just seems wrong. I know that there's been some discussion in the past about scenarios that make it hard to accurately capture how much power is in the battery, and so they very conservatively report 0% charge.
I think that buffer is done for battery longevity and counteracting degradation, in other words the bottom buffer erodes over time. I am not a fan of the Porsche way of immediately dying at 0 as well.
 
But the Escalade's efficiency is horrible, worse than any in this test. Those miles will cost you, at least in California. Not so much in regions with plentiful hydro power.
There is no region in the US where DCFC a giant battery won't be expensive, although there is argument on a longer trip if you can eliminate a DCFC session and the losses associated. Around town you can just L2 slowly at all sorts of flexible rates and times. And that doesn't even get into parity in cost with a hybrid then...
 
It doesn't bother me that much that the EPA number really isn't what I can expect when road tripping. But I do wish there was better data available to help consumers understand the impact of how they configure their vehicles. For example, when contemplating whether to get a GGT with the 20/21 or 21/22 wheels, it'd be nice to have an apples-to-apples real world highway range comparison. My sense is that the EPA numbers mislead consumers into thinking the 20/21 offers a significant range boost over 21/22, but a real world range is probably closer to 5% different.
 
Back
Top