The Insane Collapse of The "Tesla Killer"

I've never been late to anything due to my Gravity not working correctly. I've yet to pay a dime for repairs. The biggest inconvenience might be having to pick up my own complimentary rental car to drive for a few days. I've never even had to take it into service. They come to me or transport it from my driveway. Sorry for those who had a different experience, but this is far and away my favorite car we've ever owned or rode in.
I actually love sending my AGT for service and try out different trims of Air and even Gravity once.
 
I think posturing Lucid as the "Tesla Killer" is an extreme exaggeration.

Inasmuch as I am not a fan of Tesla and its leadership, one has to give Tesla a lot of credit for ushering in the EV industry worldwide. Tesla took a holistic approach, from drive train to battery to software to charging to service, and on-and-on.

Lucid's focus has been mostly drivetrain and cabin. Everything else were pretty pedestrian.

Lucid, both the Air and Gravity, are nice designs. But Lucid failed to establish the holistic system especially software, service, and customer care.

I hope Napoli can effect changes to keepp Lucid in the game.
From what I have seen recently, it appears that he understands what is needed and executing on that.
 
Have you driven one 400 miles straight? And then for a week until I could get a different rental? My assessment is based on objective criteria.
Ah yes, the Mercedes S580, apparently a chore to drive. The S-Class has been the benchmark for full-size luxury sedans for decades. Competitors have come and gone, entire nameplates have disappeared, yet the S-Class continues to define the segment. There’s a reason it’s practically synonymous with the luxury sedan. But apparently 400 miles in a rental was enough to overturn decades of automotive engineering and industry recognition. Fascinating.

And I’d genuinely love to hear your definition of “objective criteria.” Because so far, you’ve offered a personal experience and presented it as an objective conclusion. Those are two very different things. You can prefer the Lucid. That’s perfectly reasonable. But pretending the S580 is somehow an objectively inferior driving experience because you didn’t enjoy your rental is quite the leap.
 
We have all endured with patience and the occasional grumbling. The video saying that there was a $380 million compensation package; while the promises of better self driving evaporated, has me asking some hard questions. The fact is I purchased a good looking car that has ok range and great acceleration. That will not motivate me to purchase another Lucid in the short term, coupled with the fact that the Lucid Air is clearly unable to have a reliable path to an upgrade unless the nvidia board is upgraded and the supporting subsystems are modified. I was seriously looking at the Gravity, but they went the taxi route. I hope I am genuinely wrong, but the facts have me looking in the mirror. and no I won't be purchased a tesla anytime soon.
 
They are not "jumping" into Cosmos.

The real obstaclesa are,

> Cosmos is targeted at a more cost sensitive mass market with many competitors.
> Lucid's DNA is to make fancy "Gee-Wiz" cars.
> the lack of a broad service network is a stumbling block
> late to market (for a $45k to $50k) entry

It will be an uphill battle!
It would be nice if the Nvidia Thor chips went to the Lucid Air owners too, instead of only to the cost sensitive mass market. The details of the nvidia stack on Air vs. Gravity vs. Cosmos tell me only when thing; I was taken advantage of.
 
I've never been late to anything due to my Gravity not working correctly. I've yet to pay a dime for repairs. The biggest inconvenience might be having to pick up my own complimentary rental car to drive for a few days. I've never even had to take it into service. They come to me or transport it from my driveway. Sorry for those who had a different experience, but this is far and away my favorite car we've ever owned or rode in.
Don't be too smug. Your experience sounds great. So was mine until 6 weeks ago. No repairs required for 3 years and 50,000 miles. Then things changed. I'm still waiting on diagnosis and repair on my Lucid. I've been back to the service center to retrieve the "repaired car". Was told no problem found. This was after it would go no more than 50 mph (first limited to 2 mph but a deep sleep got me to 50). Problem was continuously present while I drove home (100 miles) and for 3 days while I waited for service. It was still present for the 40 mile drive to the service center and still showing when I dropped the car off. Yet 3 weeks later when I went to pick up the "repaired car" I was told they did a full check and no problem was found.
 
I actually love sending my AGT for service and try out different trims of Air and even Gravity once.
I would feel the same if I ever got an actual Lucid Loaner instead of getting stuck with a crappy ICE vehicle from Enterprise.
 
Ah yes, the Mercedes S580, apparently a chore to drive. The S-Class has been the benchmark for full-size luxury sedans for decades. Competitors have come and gone, entire nameplates have disappeared, yet the S-Class continues to define the segment. There’s a reason it’s practically synonymous with the luxury sedan. But apparently 400 miles in a rental was enough to overturn decades of automotive engineering and industry recognition. Fascinating.

And I’d genuinely love to hear your definition of “objective criteria.” Because so far, you’ve offered a personal experience and presented it as an objective conclusion. Those are two very different things. You can prefer the Lucid. That’s perfectly reasonable. But pretending the S580 is somehow an objectively inferior driving experience because you didn’t enjoy your rental is quite the leap


No leap at all and yes the MB is a relative chore to drive. Importantly, my comment was to simply put the attributes of Lucid in perspective given the ominous implications of the video above. Do you own an MB S580 or is your opinion based on received, conventional wisdom? How much seat time do you have in an AGT? I have only driven an MB S580 recently for two weeks and far prefer my AGT, which has a much more communicative suspension, better cornering, more manageable size, easier turn-in, far better throttle response and is easier to live with. Hey, buy an S580 and sell your current car or if you own one enjoy it. To quote the Dude: It's my opinion man.
 
@victoryroad

Ah, so we’ve gone from “my assessment is based on objective criteria” to “it’s my opinion, man.” Glad we finally cleared that up.

And yes, I’ve owned both an S-Class and a Lucid Air, so spare me the lecture about seat time. You’re comparing two fundamentally different vehicles and apparently struggling to understand why they drive differently. The S-Class is a full size luxury sedan engineered primarily around comfort, isolation and refinement. The Air is a performance oriented electric sedan that happens to offer comparable interior space. One is approximately 59.2 inches tall, the other 55.4. Different proportions, different engineering priorities, different driving experiences. Shocking, I know. And congratulations on discovering that a lower, performance-oriented EV has sharper throttle response and cornering than a luxury sedan designed to isolate its occupants from the road.

And for the record, preferring your Air is perfectly reasonable. Calling the S580 a “chore to drive” and presenting your personal preference as objective fact is what makes your argument ridiculous. But I’m glad we’ve finally established that it’s just your opinion. That was my point from the beginning.
 
Don't be too smug. Your experience sounds great. So was mine until 6 weeks ago. No repairs required for 3 years and 50,000 miles. Then things changed. I'm still waiting on diagnosis and repair on my Lucid. I've been back to the service center to retrieve the "repaired car". Was told no problem found. This was after it would go no more than 50 mph (first limited to 2 mph but a deep sleep got me to 50). Problem was continuously present while I drove home (100 miles) and for 3 days while I waited for service. It was still present for the 40 mile drive to the service center and still showing when I dropped the car off. Yet 3 weeks later when I went to pick up the "repaired car" I was told they did a full check and no problem was found.
“Full check, no problem found”.

That was me 3 drive system failures and 50 days in service ago.
 
In real world tests they aren’t really that more efficient, and sometimes worse. And even when better it’s by a few percentage. I would say that’s meaningless to most consimers and the market agrees.

It’s like when Nissan tried to market their “VCT Engines” as though any consumer cared. Huge flop.
“In real world tests they aren’t really that more efficient, and sometimes worse.” If we want more than noise in the forum let’s produce receipts.
 
@victoryroad

Ah, so we’ve gone from “my assessment is based on objective criteria” to “it’s my opinion, man.” Glad we finally cleared that up.

And yes, I’ve owned both an S-Class and a Lucid Air, so spare me the lecture about seat time. You’re comparing two fundamentally different vehicles and apparently struggling to understand why they drive differently. The S-Class is a full size luxury sedan engineered primarily around comfort, isolation and refinement. The Air is a performance oriented electric sedan that happens to offer comparable interior space. One is approximately 59.2 inches tall, the other 55.4. Different proportions, different engineering priorities, different driving experiences. Shocking, I know. And congratulations on discovering that a lower, performance-oriented EV has sharper throttle response and cornering than a luxury sedan designed to isolate its occupants from the road.

And for the record, preferring your Air is perfectly reasonable. Calling the S580 a “chore to drive” and presenting your personal preference as objective fact is what makes your argument ridiculous. But I’m glad we’ve finally established that it’s just your opinion. That was my point from the beginning.
Not a lecture just a quesiton. Your choice of a 2026 MB S580 over an AGT is wonderful for you. I am sorry that you are so exercised and angry with your snarky replies about my post. That you denigrate my opinion and observations are unique on this forum, which I see you only recently joined. If you have something constructive to share please do, otherwise please do not criticise others for expressing their views.
 
Back
Top