Which would you rather have for your young company?
You have a car that costs you $30k to make.
100k customers who pay you $70k each?
Or 200k customers who pay you $50k each?
You might say, well that’s the same profit. Until you realize now you have twice as many service requests. Twice as many warranty repairs. Twice as many replacement parts you need to keep in stock. Twice the server load. Increased bug reports. More staff for your customer service. More service center leases. More service technicians to train. More factory workers. More lawyers.
I don’t know. Give me niche but upscale over serving the masses any day. At least until you have time to actually work out how to scale.
That's a fine hypothetical but we have cold, hard sales data to look at. Luxury SUVs with an average sales price of $70k in the US means we're comparing the Cosmos with the X5 and GLE. Both of those combined don't sell 100k units annually in the US. Only the Lexus RX sells more than 100k units in this segment but it tops out at $70k so the volume seller is nowhere near that price. So the question becomes, would you rather sell 15k-30k units at $70k or 50k-65k units at $50k during the first couple of years? And at best over the next decade, you're selling 40-55k units at 70k vs 150k+ at 50k.
That changes the equation, doesn't it?
Also, auto sales is pretty much a zero sum game. It's just not one that a single company can win. When brands rise, they take from their competitors. Just look at the Chinese auto market and what EV sales have done to European brands. Honda and Toyota took the entire sedan market from American companies decades ago, and now Hyundai wants to take from them. But the sedan market is also being destroyed by SUVs in general, not just in the US but across the world. Those same American companies don't want the Toyota Tundra to do well because they don't want their cash cow pickups to be slaughtered. Lucid and Rivian want to do the same thing to established brands. If they don't take enough sales from those brands then they'll go bankrupt.
You can see this playing out in the Chinese market at a much faster pace. New EV brands need every sale they can get so they can survive longer than other new brands. Some of them have already failed. Now the survivors want to export across the world as Chinese domestic sales flag which no country with an automotive industry wants because they're afraid those cheap EVs will destroy manufacturing jobs as sales drop. Countries with no automotive industry don't have that incentive. We're going to see the big global car companies like Toyota and VW show declining sales
by small amounts as cheap Chinese cars flood those small markets.
And I’m sorry, but the notion that $60 or $70k is out of reach for most people doesn’t jive with current car sales around the world.
This is a crazy statement. For the three largest car markets in the world, the US is first with an average new car sales price at $50k. Europe as a whole is at $39k. China is $23k. An average sales price of $70k absolutely reduces your customer base by a lot. Can Lucid survive off a smaller base? Maybe. But it's telling that even the traditional luxury brands have always moved down market in search of more revenue/profit. And you can always look at global sales figures by brand. You have to go down to 12th place to find a brand that is a traditional luxury name, BMW.