Cosmos incoming ……

A phone call and a bribe away from being fixed.
It's only 10% right now, plus whatever shipping costs is paid by the other imported cars to USA which is the same for all the automakers.
I don't think they are aiming to compete with the Model Y. They may take some sales from the top end trims but that's not the main target.

They are aiming for the Volvo/BMW/MB mid-size Luxury SUV market. The model Y isn't really a luxury product.
Especially since it';s going to be discontinued in the next 3-5 years, Elon said the only car with steering wheel you can buy and drive yourself in the future is the roadster.
 
50k minimum over 10 years is essentially meaningless. That commitment won't help Lucid survive if Cosmos is not successful.

If Cosmos doesn't sell close to 50k in its first year of production alone then Lucid probably won't survive.
That's a bit harsh, by that logic you are saying Rivian is guaranteed to go under then, they are nowhere near 50K R2s, still lose money on all of them and have runway to Q1 2028.
 
Disagree, 1st year production will be 10k? Those 10k may well go to those who don’t mind spending 70k. It’s a trickle down effect…..Rivuan base model isn’t coming out for another 6 months.

If Lucid can't build and sell more than 10k units of their mass market model in the first full year of production then this company is truly incompetent and deserves to fail. Tesla was able to crap out tens of thousands of Model 3s in the first year of production on its way to 140k+ units over the first 1.5 calendar years while finishing them in an outdoor tent. Rivian is going to build ~25k R2s in the second half of this year alone with projections of 60k+ next year. The R2 is also supposedly more parts heavy than the Cosmos/Midsize and the first Model 3 was incredibly more complex than both the R2 and Cosmos.

What exactly is Lucid doing? I understand that KSA/PIF has essentially blackmailed/bribed/coerced Lucid into a terrible business decision with AMP-2's timeline but they desperately need to build more than 9k cars out of that plant in the first year. Or bring AMP-1's Cosmos line online within months of AMP-2's launch. Because 9k Cosmos at $60k is $540M. This is a company that's still burning just over $1 billion every quarter after a lot of cost cutting.

The goal of a car manufacturer is to build and sell enough cars to be self-sustaining. The goal is not to design "the best car" possible.
 
If Lucid can't build and sell more than 10k units of their mass market model in the first full year of production then this company is truly incompetent and deserves to fail. Tesla was able to crap out tens of thousands of Model 3s in the first year of production on its way to 140k+ units over the first 1.5 calendar years while finishing them in an outdoor tent. Rivian is going to build ~25k R2s in the second half of this year alone with projections of 60k+ next year. The R2 is also supposedly more parts heavy than the Cosmos/Midsize and the first Model 3 was incredibly more complex than both the R2 and Cosmos.

What exactly is Lucid doing? I understand that KSA/PIF has essentially blackmailed/bribed/coerced Lucid into a terrible business decision with AMP-2's timeline but they desperately need to build more than 9k cars out of that plant in the first year. Or bring AMP-1's Cosmos line online within months of AMP-2's launch. Because 9k Cosmos at $60k is $540k. This is a company that's still burning just over $1 billion every quarter after a lot of cost cutting.

The goal of a car manufacturer is to build and sell enough cars to be self-sustaining. The goal is not to design "the best car" possible.
9k x $60k is $540 M.
 
That's a bit harsh, by that logic you are saying Rivian is guaranteed to go under then, they are nowhere near 50K R2s, still lose money on all of them and have runway to Q1 2028.

Rivian is going to produce and sell ~25k R2s in the second half of this year alone. They're projecting 60k+ for all of 2027 for a total of 85k in 1.5 years. They clear that 50k unit goal easily. Even then, Rivian is not guaranteed to survive. Lucid hasn't announced projections for Cosmos yet, for good reason. If they come out and say 9k is what they're making in the first year then their stock price is going to crater even further.

KSA is absolutely pinky-promising to buy 50k TOTAL over 10 years and if Lucid is a really good boy they'll buy 50k more over those 10 years. So 5-10k per year over 10 years. This is essentially a rounding error for a major carmaker.
 
Last edited:
you are asking people to buy a car from a company they never heard of with barely any showrooms to see them with a dicey reputation for quality and made in saudi arabia which has no history at all of making cars. pricing aside i can think of some better scenarios. what, me worry
 
Wow, people are not reading clearly today.

I said the average Cosmos will be $70k.

The base price will be $49k, as promised.

The average will be higher, because the type of person who wants this car will want some options. Just as the average Model Y is not its base $40k.

Sure, some will go for the cheapest thing possible. But the base is there to get you in the door. It’s not the target.

Higher average selling price is a good thing. How could it possibly be otherwise? Most of the options are highly profitable.

The base model makes the manufacturer the least money. Why on Earth would you make it your goal to sell as many of the least profitable model as possible?
 
And I’m sorry, but the notion that $60 or $70k is out of reach for most people doesn’t jive with current car sales around the world.

No, not everyone can afford that. But Lucid is nowhere near needing to sell to everyone.

Have you seen the price of most people’s pickup trucks?
 
This is not a zero sum game. Lucid doesn’t literally have to make every car buyer on the planet buy a Lucid to succeed. We all get that, right?
 
This is not a zero sum game. Lucid doesn’t literally have to make every car buyer on the planet buy a Lucid to succeed. We all get that, right?
Sadly it looks like spelling out this nuance to those that need to hear it will fall to deaf ears. Judging by the prior responses to this thread, it looks like some people are expecting Lucid to be pumping Cosmos out of AMP-2 with double or triple shifts flat-out the moment they're in full production.

And before anyone tries to jump and go for my throat, sure I'd love to know Lucid's ramp-up plan too but that information is not public. The most we can do is sit, wait, and see
 
Which would you rather have for your young company?

You have a car that costs you $30k to make.

100k customers who pay you $70k each?

Or 200k customers who pay you $50k each?

You might say, well that’s the same profit. Until you realize now you have twice as many service requests. Twice as many warranty repairs. Twice as many replacement parts you need to keep in stock. Twice the server load. Increased bug reports. More staff for your customer service. More service center leases. More service technicians to train. More factory workers. More lawyers.

I don’t know. Give me niche but upscale over serving the masses any day. At least until you have time to actually work out how to scale.
 
Twice as many warranty repairs. Twice as many replacement parts you need to keep in stock. Twice the server load. Increased bug reports. More staff for your customer service. More service center leases. More service technicians to train. More factory workers. More lawyers.

And… twice as many customers to share their amazing experiences.

Seriously, I do get your point.
 
Which would you rather have for your young company?

You have a car that costs you $30k to make.

100k customers who pay you $70k each?

Or 200k customers who pay you $50k each?

You might say, well that’s the same profit. Until you realize now you have twice as many service requests. Twice as many warranty repairs. Twice as many replacement parts you need to keep in stock. Twice the server load. Increased bug reports. More staff for your customer service. More service center leases. More service technicians to train. More factory workers. More lawyers.

I don’t know. Give me niche but upscale over serving the masses any day. At least until you have time to actually work out how to scale.
Sure this all makes sense for a company with a solid balance sheet and flush with cash. That's not Lucid. They have an accumulated deficit of $18.5B. But for a single investor willing to pour billions into the company it would have closed its doors years ago. And that investor has its own set of priorities and expectations for the company. And they don't seem to be scaling up to capture a niche market. If they were there's ample capacity at AMP-1 to accomplish that objective.

Tesla succeeded because it was able to transition its vehicles from aspirational to attainable. A car with a an average sale price of $70K is not attainable for most buyers particularly if its being sold globally. Of course Lucid doesn't have to sell 100's of thousands of cars. But few car companies can make it over the long term if they don't. And at some point the KSA/PIF will expect to earn something on their investment.
 
Which would you rather have for your young company?

You have a car that costs you $30k to make.

100k customers who pay you $70k each?

Or 200k customers who pay you $50k each?

You might say, well that’s the same profit. Until you realize now you have twice as many service requests. Twice as many warranty repairs. Twice as many replacement parts you need to keep in stock. Twice the server load. Increased bug reports. More staff for your customer service. More service center leases. More service technicians to train. More factory workers. More lawyers.

I don’t know. Give me niche but upscale over serving the masses any day. At least until you have time to actually work out how to scale.

That's a fine hypothetical but we have cold, hard sales data to look at. Luxury SUVs with an average sales price of $70k in the US means we're comparing the Cosmos with the X5 and GLE. Both of those combined don't sell 100k units annually in the US. Only the Lexus RX sells more than 100k units in this segment but it tops out at $70k so the volume seller is nowhere near that price. So the question becomes, would you rather sell 15k-30k units at $70k or 50k-65k units at $50k during the first couple of years? And at best over the next decade, you're selling 40-55k units at 70k vs 150k+ at 50k.

That changes the equation, doesn't it?

Also, auto sales is pretty much a zero sum game. It's just not one that a single company can win. When brands rise, they take from their competitors. Just look at the Chinese auto market and what EV sales have done to European brands. Honda and Toyota took the entire sedan market from American companies decades ago, and now Hyundai wants to take from them. But the sedan market is also being destroyed by SUVs in general, not just in the US but across the world. Those same American companies don't want the Toyota Tundra to do well because they don't want their cash cow pickups to be slaughtered. Lucid and Rivian want to do the same thing to established brands. If they don't take enough sales from those brands then they'll go bankrupt.

You can see this playing out in the Chinese market at a much faster pace. New EV brands need every sale they can get so they can survive longer than other new brands. Some of them have already failed. Now the survivors want to export across the world as Chinese domestic sales flag which no country with an automotive industry wants because they're afraid those cheap EVs will destroy manufacturing jobs as sales drop. Countries with no automotive industry don't have that incentive. We're going to see the big global car companies like Toyota and VW show declining sales by small amounts as cheap Chinese cars flood those small markets.

And I’m sorry, but the notion that $60 or $70k is out of reach for most people doesn’t jive with current car sales around the world.

This is a crazy statement. For the three largest car markets in the world, the US is first with an average new car sales price at $50k. Europe as a whole is at $39k. China is $23k. An average sales price of $70k absolutely reduces your customer base by a lot. Can Lucid survive off a smaller base? Maybe. But it's telling that even the traditional luxury brands have always moved down market in search of more revenue/profit. And you can always look at global sales figures by brand. You have to go down to 12th place to find a brand that is a traditional luxury name, BMW.
 
Sigh. I’m just going to stop here. If you think Lucid is ready to serve 100k plus customers per year, go for it. I’d like some of what you are smoking.
 
Sigh. I’m just going to stop here. If you think Lucid is ready to serve 100k plus customers per year, go for it. I’d like some of what you are smoking.

Who argued they needed to be ready? I sure didn't. Tesla wasn't ready. Rivian isn't ready. But they all needed the cashflow to continue operating. Lucid is no different. You said that Lucid would be fine selling Cosmos for an average of $70k. I'm arguing that Lucid is not going to have the cashflow to survive if they do that.

But sure, have a good evening.
 
It's only 10% right now, plus whatever shipping costs is paid by the other imported cars to USA which is the same for all the automakers.

Especially since it';s going to be discontinued in the next 3-5 years, Elon said the only car with steering wheel you can buy and drive yourself in the future is the roadster.
Good luck to him /s
 
Sigh. I’m just going to stop here. If you think Lucid is ready to serve 100k plus customers per year, go for it. I’d like some of what you are smoking.
Agreed here. And Lucid's messaging aligns with what you're saying. Looks like they're targeting a slow ramp of Cosmos at AMP-2, with production being the bottleneck, not demand. This is absolutely the right move IMO.

If demand>production, then they (1) would be able to drive profits quicker with less discounting, (2) would be in a good position to raise capital and (3) can be strategic with building out their sales and service network. The last thing they want is to produce 100k vehicles in the first year. They simply don't have the infrastructure for that.
 
And yet they have no problem selling them. Lot’s of them in fact. But I’m with you. The best strategy is to sell a bespoke vehicle that only a select few will appreciate.
No problem selling because they are cheaper than Garavity/Air, more service availability stable software. It’s not a reflection of product interior being luxurious. Their sales have actually peaked.
 
Back
Top